Lawmakers last summer enacted a bill of
attainder targeting Huawei, a successful, privately owned and operated Chinese technology company.
This violates the Bill of
Attainder Clause and the Due Process Clause.
Huawei's lawsuit argues that by singling out the company, Congress has violated constitutional principles on the separation of powers and also the bill of
attainder clause, which prohibits legislation that singles out a person or entity for punishment without trial.
Huawei says it is the target of an unconstitutional "bill of
attainder," in which a person or entity is found guilty of a crime via an act of legislation, and argues that the law violates its right to due process and is a violation of the separation of powers between Congress and other branches of government.
According to the paper's sources, the tech giant would argue that the motion basically amounts to a "bill of
attainder" -- or a legislative act singling out a person or an entity for punishment without trial.
That misstates the originality of the claim: The Constitution before the Bill of Rights already protected critical individual rights, including the right to a jury trial in criminal cases and prohibition against retroactive laws and bills of
attainder. (28) The supremacy clause of the Constitution, prior to the Bill of Rights, had already provided that the U.S.
"The Congress shall have the Power to declare the Punishment of Treason, but no
Attainder of Treason shall work Corruption of Blood or Forfeiture except during the Life of the Person attainted."
The utility claimed that the rate reduction and other aspects of the new laws "constitute an unlawful taking of private property, deny it due process of law, and constitute an unlawful bill of
attainder, all in violation of various provisions of the United States Constitution."
There is a constitutional prohibition on acts of
attainder, otherwise I suppose Imran Khan would ask for one.
Some words are unambiguously technical terms, such as the constitutional term "Bill of
Attainder." (73) These words have a legal meaning, but no ordinary language meaning.
In his letter, Hadsor refers to Henry Chettle's Cardinal Wolsey when relating the current earl of Kildare's attempts to retrieve the lands that were taken from his grandfather-Thomas FitzGerald, the 10th earl of Kildare--following his
attainder, that is, legal death.
The Bill of
Attainder Clause prohibits the legislature from determining the guilt or innocence of a particular party or prescribing an appropriate punishment for a particular party.
(27) In the words of legal historian William Stacy, by the abandonment of the trial and the move to a bill of
attainder the House of Commons "destroyed a man they otherwise could not convict." (28)
before
attainder, sentence or conviction, or after, forgiveth any crime,
Punishments of this sort are extremely common historically: outlawry, infamy, exile, excommunication,
attainder, and civil death form a chain of exclusionary punishments across the centuries.