Lisa's Reviews > Prisoners of Geography: Ten Maps That Tell You Everything You Need to Know About Global Politics

Prisoners of Geography by Tim  Marshall
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
32532774
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: nonfiction

This is an amazing journey through the world, zooming out of particular localities and looking at the geographical shape of bigger areas that helped form the history, culture and population of the world we share.

I read the first chapters on Russia, China, Europe, USA and Africa constantly nodding my head, realising that it was possible to explain many things I had thought about for long hours by analysing natural borders, rivers, mountains, vegetation, climate and distribution of agricultural opportunities. I had the feeling that my historical knowledge became deeper, and more nuanced by adding the dimension of geography.

My recent reflections on Chinua Achebe were put into the context of the vast African continent and its geography. The story of I Am Malala: The Story of the Girl Who Stood Up for Education and Was Shot by the Taliban gained width and depth through my intense staring at the map of the borders between Pakistan, India and Afghanistan, and I learned a great deal from the historical references to that region.

Then I embarked on the chapter about South America, a continent I hardly know, and was plunged into a strong childhood memory, all of a sudden, without any warning. Reading about Brazil and its complicated connections to other countries, comparing it to Argentina with its access to the Atlantic through the Rio De La Plata, I found myself repeatedly humming a song by a Swedish sailor-poet-songwriter called Evert Taube. My father used to sing his songs to me when I was little, and I still know them by heart, but I have never thought of them in terms of global geography. However, this lovely love song between a Swedish sailor and a young girl called Carmencita from Samborombom, in the Rio De La Plata area, shows exactly what this nonfiction book on geography explains in plain facts: some areas are more accessible, and enhance global communication, while others are more remote, and thus stay isolated, culturally and technologically. The Swedish sailor in the song meets the exotic young lady because his ship has access to her country, but when he wants to marry her, she refuses, telling him her father has received an offer, and she will marry a local man who owns 20,000 cows. Fritjof has to sail home again, his (doubtful) virtues and wonderful tango skills are not enough!

Samborombon, en liten by förutan gata,
den ligger inte långt från Rio de la Plata,
nästan i kanten av den blåa Atlanten och med
pampas bakom sej många hundra gröna mil,
dit kom jag ridande en afton i april
för jag ville dansa Tango.

Fully aware that Swedish is not a global language, I still feel I have to copy these Evert Taube lines here, because they connected me to the big, wide world when I was a child, and now made me appreciate the accuracy of the historical impact of geography on a much more personal level.

I was coming to the end of the book at this point, and Evert Taube brought it to my attention that I had actually not read anything about Scandinavia's geography yet. This is a region I consider my own, and I can't emphasise enough how astonished I was to realise that it is mentioned, at the very end, not in the chapter on Europe, or in the context of the Western Hemisphere, but as part of the ARCTIC. I had to spend a lot of time meditating on the map showing my home town well within the area circling the arctic, and reflecting on what it possibly meant to me. Also, contrary to Swedish wisdom (beware, this might be irony imported from the continent!), Norway was in the focus of the Scandinavian chapter. How could that be? I thoroughly enjoyed my own confusion at having my geography skills put into perspective like that.

One last thing, before I recommend this book to anyone interested in the overarching connections between history and geography: I don't like the subtitle at all and it almost put me off trying the book!

Ten Maps That tell You Everything....

That made me think it must be one of those books pretending to explain the world to you in a short, poorly written bestseller style.

Ten recipes that make you lose weight in two days...

Ten tricks to save money when shopping...

This book does NOT tell you everything, and that is good, but it gives you insight into an aspect of global developments that enhances your previous knowledge and makes you curious to learn more!

Read! Despite subtitle! (And my overuse of exclamation marks!)!
94 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Prisoners of Geography.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

August 22, 2016 – Started Reading
August 22, 2016 – Shelved
August 22, 2016 – Shelved as: to-read
August 27, 2016 –
page 59
23.05% "Excellent so far!"
August 27, 2016 –
page 111
43.36% "The chapters on Russia and China, as well as USA, are outstanding."
August 28, 2016 –
page 144
56.25% "Reading the Africa chapter while spending the day in the company of a pile of Chinua Achebe books is very enlightening!"
August 29, 2016 –
page 184
71.88%
August 30, 2016 –
page 212
82.81%
August 31, 2016 –
page 220
85.94%
September 1, 2016 –
page 237
92.58%
September 3, 2016 – Shelved as: nonfiction
September 3, 2016 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-21 of 21 (21 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Ray (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ray I found this to be an excellent book. Glad to see that you like it too


Lisa Yes, Ray, I find myself enjoying every single chapter. And I originally bought it to read it for work - but now it is purely for my own pleasure and understanding!


message 3: by Ray (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ray another book that touches similar themes is "guns germs and steel" by Jared Diamond


Lisa We definitely like the same books - that is on my shelf as well! I bought them together. I am happy to hear it is a good read, too, as I am starting it as soon as I have finished this one.


message 5: by Dolors (new)

Dolors Your reviews never fail to be highly informative and equally entertaining, Lisa. Your last lines drew a smile on my face. In a way, they echo the visual effect this book on maps transcending the barriers of geography and languages...


Lisa Jean-Paul wrote: "Thank you Lisa for this informative review which I took great pleasure in reading and felt exactly the same sensation as you when things "gained width and depth". After reading Bouvier, I came to u..."

Thank you, Jean-Paul! It is nice when you discover new islands on your reading odyssey, isn't it?


Lisa Dolors wrote: "Your reviews never fail to be highly informative and equally entertaining, Lisa. Your last lines drew a smile on my face. In a way, they echo the visual effect this book on maps transcending the ba..."

I am happy it made you smile, Dolors! Nothing like a smile on a Saturday morning. And you treated me to Orlando at the same time, which is competing in an entirely different league :-)


Lisa Ray wrote: "another book that touches similar themes is "guns germs and steel" by Jared Diamond"

Now I am starting on Guns, Germs and Steels, hoping to gain another layer of understanding! Which one did you prefer?


message 9: by Ray (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ray Lisa wrote: "Ray wrote: "another book that touches similar themes is "guns germs and steel" by Jared Diamond"

Now I am starting on Guns, Germs and Steels, hoping to gain another layer of understanding! Which o..."


I think Guns if only because it opened up a whole new view to me. It is also much more in depth - Ten Maps is like a starter, with Guns being the main course.

Great review by the way.


message 10: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Ray wrote: "Lisa wrote: "Ray wrote: "another book that touches similar themes is "guns germs and steel" by Jared Diamond"

Now I am starting on Guns, Germs and Steels, hoping to gain another layer of understan..."


Thank you Ray! And after Guns for main course, I think I will have David Christian's Maps of Time for dessert :-)


message 11: by Ray (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ray Maps of time I do not know. Will look out for your review


message 12: by Cecily (new)

Cecily I'd seen mention of this book, and dismissed it largely on the basis of the hyperbolic click-bait title. I'm glad to know it's better than that.


message 13: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Cecily wrote: "I'd seen mention of this book, and dismissed it largely on the basis of the hyperbolic click-bait title. I'm glad to know it's better than that."

It's funny that the title has such an impact, positive or negative, depending on what kind of reader you are. I thought of that all the time while exploring this book.


message 14: by Lyn (new) - added it

Lyn Elliott Interesting review Kisa, thank you. You might also enjoy Robert Kaplan's Revenge of Geography, which is one of those books full of insights which lead you to say 'of course, why didn't I see that before' and 'yes, that puts my thoughts into a wider context'. And I'm happy on the whole that Australia doesn't make the list of top 10 locations of geopolitical interest. Quite a relief, in fact.


message 15: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Lyn wrote: "Interesting review Kisa, thank you. You might also enjoy Robert Kaplan's Revenge of Geography, which is one of those books full of insights which lead you to say 'of course, why didn't I see that b..."

I will definitely pick up your suggestion, Lyn! Thanks a lot!


message 16: by Will (new) - added it

Will Growing up on the East Coast of the US, even close cities seemed far away. Two hours was stretching it, and six hours unheard of. Geography fascinates me precisely because where we are from determines how we view the natural, political, and social worlds. Thanks for the superb review!


message 17: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Will wrote: "Growing up on the East Coast of the US, even close cities seemed far away. Two hours was stretching it, and six hours unheard of. Geography fascinates me precisely because where we are from determi..."

Thank you, Will! I agree with you, distance in USA is quite different from continental Europe, where you have major cities within driving distance wherever you happen to be. It does indeed affect your approach to the world, and it is exciting to find out how.


Travelin This book recently made it to near the top of my TBRs, but your review and sailor's ditty reminded me that more than half the world's population lives on coasts, and that history seems to be made or changed by sailors.


message 19: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Travelin wrote: "This book recently made it to near the top of my TBRs, but your review and sailor's ditty reminded me that more than half the world's population lives on coasts, and that history seems to be made o..."

There is more than one grain of truth in that observation, Travelin! Along the rivers, by the sea, that's where humans gather.


Gayathri "This book does NOT tell you everything, and that is good, but it gives you insight into an aspect of global developments that enhances your previous knowledge and makes you curious to learn more!"
Couldn't agree more! I am 20% into the book and enjoying it very much. Nice review.


message 21: by Maricarmen (new) - added it

Maricarmen Estrada M Beautiful review Lisa! And thank you for sharing your own references of your past experience and feelings!


back to top