Jeffrey Keeten's Reviews > Macbeth

Macbeth by Jo Nesbø
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3427339
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: scotland, shakespeare, hardboiled, greed

”There is only so much a man can take before he gives in, before he breaks every tattooed oath and does everything---absolutely everything---he thought he would never do. For eternal loyalty is inhuman and betrayal is human.”

 photo Sam20Worthington20Victoria20Hill_zps3q0zaijr.jpg
The Sam Worthington and Victoria Hill Scottish Gangster version of Macbeth (2006) is my favorite Macbeth and probably the closest cinematic version to this novel.

Inverness.

1970s.

Setting: Run down industrial town with toxic air and poisoned earth. Crime is high as more and more of the population becomes addicted to an illicit drug called Brew, made in a witch’s caldron. (I know, heavy, right?) Hecate is the drug lord who, behind the scenes, manipulates everything.

Duncan is the police commissioner.

All Hail Duncan.

He is honest, and if given a chance, he will lead Inverness back to a happy better life.

So it all begins with a promotion that is given to a man named Macbeth. He is the head of SWAT, but they want to move him up to head of Organized Crime. It is a job that (Mac)Duff, his longest friend, has coveted. The decision is based off the fact that everyone in positions of power have come from the well educated, upper classes. Macbeth comes from the lower classes and was once completely strung out on Brew. Hecate, always one to sense opportunity, dispatches the witch Strega to Macbeth to share a prophecy with him. Hecate knows that Macbeth is the very guy he has been looking for to derail Duncan. ”The only person more predictable than a junkie or a moralist is a love-smitten junkie and moralist.”

Macbeth is love-smitten, indeed, with the lovely woman who calls herself Lady Macbeth. She has fiery red hair, elegance, and flair that makes men go weak in the knees. She owns the casino in town, but her ambitions go way beyond controlling gambling. She thinks Macbeth should listen to the prophecy and become police commissioner, but why stop there? Why not mayor, as well?

All Hail Macbeth.

 photo Macbeth20witches_zpsxdjafsrx.jpg
Double, double toil and trouble;
Fire burn, and cauldron bubble.


Macbeth must become someone else, someone he fought, conquered, and left bleeding in the gutter of his past. ”He had to become that other Macbeth, the one he had buried so deep, that crazy flesh-eating corpse he had sworn he would never be again.” To be that man, he needs brew. He needs brew, sliding like silver snakes through his bloodstream, to give him the courage/cowardice to kill Duncan. ”Is this a dagger which I see before me?”

Ambition achieved and yet unearned creates anxiety. Who can rest easy on the bones of their enemies when they weren’t truly their enemies, but good men more deserving? As Macbeth does more and more to friends who know too much and to those who simply stand in his way, ”Red feathers were stuck to the walls around them;” paranoia becomes his constant companion, and his weaknesses become more evidence .

He is on a collision course with Duff, who becomes the only man who has a chance to stop him.

All Hail Duff?

Out of all the plays that I’ve read by William Shakespeare, Macbeth is my favorite. I haven’t read them all so I do reserve the right to change my Shakespeare affiliation as I work my way through the Bard’s amazing contribution to English Literature. It turns out to be a terrible alliance, due to the fact that Lady and Macbeth spur each other’s ambitions which, once achieved, turn out to be hollow and too highly priced. The greed for power is strong, and like a drug, people can start to want more, always chasing the feeling of that high when they first triumphed.

Inexplicably, I’ve always liked Macbeth. I find myself, whether it is a play, a movie, or this novel, rooting for him even though he isn’t really that likeable. I see the promise in him that is overcome by the evil in him. I’m always hopeful that some writer or movie producer will pull him back from the brink and set him down on a path to be the man I know he could be. Of course, redemption is not the theme of the play, nor of any movie or book starring Macbeth. He must be consumed by his own guilt and insecurities. He must ultimately be destroyed by the weight of his misdeeds.

There are ghosts, witches, and playful uses of characters. Seyton is transformed into some creature beyond the pale of human understanding. Everything I’ve read says that Shakespeare never intended the name Seyton to infer that he was Satan, but where the Bard may have let the opportunity flitter away in rewrites, Jo Nesbo did not. Nesbo certainly has fun with the characters. Caithness, a Scottish nobleman in the play, is cast as a woman in this novel, the lover of Duff. Hecate is a witch in the play, but becomes a male drug lord in this novel. Nesbo stays reasonably close to the original plot.

 photo Macbeth20Fassbender_zpsnkrchrdr.jpg
I loved the 2015 version of Macbeth starring Michael Fassbender.

I’m really impressed with the first volume I’ve read in the Hogarth Shakespeare series. Hogarth was the original press owned by Leonard and Virginia Woolf. Next on my list will be Margaret Atwood’s retelling of The Tempest. The others in the series are Tracy Chevalier retelling Othello, Gillian FLynn retelling Hamlet, Howard Jacobson retelling The Merchant of Venice, Edward St. Aubyn retelling King Lear, Anne Tyler retelling The Taming of the Shrew, and Jeanette Winterson retelling The Winter’s Tale. If they have not commissioned your favorite play yet, stay tuned. This novel was a bloody blast. I set aside all other books to focus on reading it over the weekend and found it, frankly, invigorating. Shakespeare made into a page turner.

If you wish to see more of my most recent book and movie reviews, visit http://www.jeffreykeeten.com
I also have a Facebook blogger page at:https://www.facebook.com/JeffreyKeeten
301 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Macbeth.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 8, 2017 – Started Reading
December 8, 2017 – Shelved
December 9, 2017 – Shelved as: scotland
December 9, 2017 – Shelved as: shakespeare
December 11, 2017 – Shelved as: hardboiled
December 11, 2017 – Shelved as: greed
December 11, 2017 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 51 (51 new)


Dennis Love your review, Jeffrey! I love the story of Macbeth as well but this read was more mixed for me. I’m glad you enjoyed it!


message 2: by Lars (new) - added it

Lars Jerlach I just finished The Leopard. Perhaps I should check out the rest of Nesbø's repertoire.


Jeffrey Keeten Dennis wrote: "Love your review, Jeffrey! I love the story of Macbeth as well but this read was more mixed for me. I’m glad you enjoyed it!"

Thanks Dennis! I'm not surprised that you didn't like the book. There are going to be a lot of readers who struggle with the themes of this book just as there are many in this modern age who struggle to understand Shakespeare's plays. I have a lot of history with Macbeth so I can appreciate an author who is being true to the Bard, but also breaking completely away from the type of writing that has made him famous. I have always enjoyed Nesbo, but I have a lot more respect for him as a writer after reading this book.


message 4: by Jeffrey (last edited Dec 14, 2017 05:56PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jeffrey Keeten Lars wrote: "I just finished The Leopard. Perhaps I should check out the rest of Nesbø's repertoire."

You are ahead of me. I just finished Snowman a few weeks ago. I assume that The Leopard delivers as well. Don't Scandinavian writers have to stick together? :-) I really enjoy Nesbo. This one was pretty damn impressive.


James Thane Another very nice review, Jeffrey. Really anxious to get to this one.


Jeffrey Keeten James wrote: "Another very nice review, Jeffrey. Really anxious to get to this one."

Thanks James! I hope you enjoy it as much as I do. I sure enjoyed reading it and getting an opportunity to write a review.


Shahna Seal This is a great review! Macbeth is unlikable but somehow always has people rooting for him. Even my students root for him. He’s somewhat of a tragic hero in ways with so many flaws. I just picked up the book today. So excited.


Jeffrey Keeten Shahna wrote: "This is a great review! Macbeth is unlikable but somehow always has people rooting for him. Even my students root for him. He’s somewhat of a tragic hero in ways with so many flaws. I just picked u..."

It is a bit unnerving that I'm rooting for such a flawed character, but that really says something about the amazing writing that creates a character like this that we identify enough with that we want him to overcome his own flaws rather than just condemn him for his flaws. Thanks Shahna! I hope you enjoy it as much as I did.


message 9: by Vessey (new)

Vessey The greed for power is strong, and like a drug, people can start to want more, always chasing the feeling of that high when they first triumphed.

You reminded me of Undine Spragg from Edith Wharton’s The Custom of the Country and what I talk of in my review of it. You should read it. I mean the book. I think you'll like it :)

Inexplicably, I’ve always liked Macbeth. I find myself, whether it is a play, a movie, or this novel, rooting for him even though he isn’t really that likeable. Inexplicably, I’ve always liked Macbeth. I find myself, whether it is a play, a movie, or this novel, rooting for him even though he isn’t really that likeable. I see the promise in him that is overcome by the evil in him. I’m always hopeful that some writer or movie producer will pull him back from the brink and set him down on a path to be the man I know he could be

It is a testimony to the gift of Shakspeare and the retellers that readers can love the villains. But you have a great share in it too, because you are able to see beauty everywhere. :) You know, it was only recently, when I wrote about this TV show (okay, they are two shows, but the second one is a spin-off, so I see them as one) that I am always more impressed with characters seeking redemption, ones who achieve spiritual growth and find their strength and maturity with time and by learning from their mistakes and misdeeds than with those who are role models from beginning to end. Isn't this said in the Bible too? That God is always happier with one reformed sinner than with ten righteous ones. Or something of the likes. Ah, there it is, then. We think in the right direction. :) I'll make sure I mess up properly before dying. :) Oh, and I'll make sure I choose a sin that is fun. I wonder what could that be? Eyebrows. :)

As always, awesome review. Thanks! :)


Jeffrey Keeten Vessey wrote: "The greed for power is strong, and like a drug, people can start to want more, always chasing the feeling of that high when they first triumphed.

You reminded me of Undine Spragg from Edith Wharto..."


The problem with the righteous is that can't seem to quit being judgmental and looking down their noses at those who may have a fault or two. A reformed sinner should have more compassion for those who have sinned thus he/she would be much more useful to a God intent on converting sinners to his cult erhh I mean religion.

Thanks Vessey! Macbeth is definitely one of my favorite characters from Shakespeare.


message 11: by Lynn (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lynn Great review Jeffrey! I’m looking forward to this book.


Jeffrey Keeten Lynn wrote: "Great review Jeffrey! I’m looking forward to this book."

Thanks Lynn! It was right in my wheelhouse.


message 13: by Vessey (new)

Vessey Jeffrey wrote: "Vessey wrote: "The greed for power is strong, and like a drug, people can start to want more, always chasing the feeling of that high when they first triumphed.

You reminded me of Undine Spragg fr..."


Yes, I know what you mean. In my review of Inferno I say that I would always choose a sinner who forgives over the one who doesn’t sin, but never forgives either. And it’s true that sometimes our own failures make us more tolerant. It has happened to me. But what’s even worse than what you described is when you are guilty of the very thing you blame someone for or worse. In Vikings, when the Vikings attack and kill the king’s people and one of theirs dies too, they start talking about how even the king has to pay for his death. And I have been thinking about it ever since I saw this episode, because it happens in reality all the time. I wonder at the temerity of people who have such a view, who do something horrible and then actually feel violated and act like they are completely innocent. They not just demonstrate it, they seem to genuinely believe that they are wronged, that only they have the right to do a certain thing and when it turns out that they have to face consequences, they believe themselves to be victims.


message 14: by Glenn (last edited Jun 25, 2018 01:21PM) (new) - added it

Glenn Russell Outstanding, Jeffrey. On the strength of your review I'm listening to the audio. Usually a Brit narrates Jo's books but in this case, appropriately, the narrator is a Scotsman, Euan Morton. What a story! You gotta love those Norse Riders, red haired Lady at the casino, the new city drug called "Brew"! I'm having fun with this - should have my review posted by mid-July.


Jeffrey Keeten Glenn wrote: "Outstanding, Jeffrey. On the strength of your review I'm listening to the audio. Usually a Brit narrates Jo's books but in this case, appropriately, the narrator is a Scotsman, Euan Morton. What a ..."

Thanks Glenn! I'm glad you are enjoying it. The reviews have been mixed, but I had a blast with it. I look forward to your review.


message 16: by Glenn (new) - added it

Glenn Russell Jeffrey wrote: "Glenn wrote: "Outstanding, Jeffrey. On the strength of your review I'm listening to the audio. Usually a Brit narrates Jo's books but in this case, appropriately, the narrator is a Scotsman, Euan M..."

Thanks, Jeffrey. I saw the mixed reviews. But based on your review and James Shapiro's New York Times review, this novel is a winner. James Shapiro has been teaching Shakespeare at Columbia University for 40 years and his review is glowing, where he ends with: "Nesbo is less interested in the original’s verbal texture than he is in adapting its plot and delving into the moral choices confronting its characters. In the end, he offers a dark but ultimately hopeful “Macbeth,” one suited to our own troubled times, in which “the slowness of democracy” is no match for power-hungry strongmen who demand unstinting loyalty from ethically compromised followers, and where the brave must band together to defeat the darker forces that threaten to destroy the social fabric."


Jeffrey Keeten Glenn wrote: "Jeffrey wrote: "Glenn wrote: "Outstanding, Jeffrey. On the strength of your review I'm listening to the audio. Usually a Brit narrates Jo's books but in this case, appropriately, the narrator is a ..."

I'm in good company with James Shapiro! I agree with his assessment. Hopefully your review will convince some of the skeptics!


Shelley Thanks for such an in-depth review (without spoiling the story.) I think I will acquire a copy of Macbeth and get back to you later once I've read it.


Jeffrey Keeten Shelley wrote: "Thanks for such an in-depth review (without spoiling the story.) I think I will acquire a copy of Macbeth and get back to you later once I've read it."

If you especially enjoy the original story you will appreciate Nesbo's homage. Thanks Shelley! You are most welcome!


Shelley Hi Jeffrey. I just finished this book and very much enjoyed it.


Jeffrey Keeten Glad you enjoyed the book Shelley!


Shelley Thanks. I can comiserate with people who have difficulty getting into this novel. I did initially, but took a patient a pproach and was well rewarded. It's so dark on many levels. The atmoshere is very uncomfortable. There's such a feeling of heaviness and forboding. Jo nesbo outdid himself on this one. He is an estremely skillful writer; It was a courageous departure from his usual work. This was so powerful and vibrant. He made great use of "Bertha" toward the end - the crushing inevitable force of such a stationary, seemingly imovable object. This world will be in my mind for some time to come.


Jeffrey Keeten Shelley wrote: "Thanks. I can comiserate with people who have difficulty getting into this novel. I did initially, but took a patient a pproach and was well rewarded. It's so dark on many levels. The atmoshere is ..."

Unfortunately a lot of people hear Shakespeare and instantly decide it is not for them. Of course I love the play Macbeth and I'm a big Nesbo fan so this was like finding two of my favorite foods on my plate. Bacon wrapped shrimp! :-) There is so much going on in this novel I could definitely see myself reading it again in the future. I intend to read most of the Hogarth Shakespeare books. I really enjoyed the Margaret Atwood one as well. I have the Anne Tyler so that will probably be the next Hogarth for me.


Shelley More people should read Shakespeare as his work seems to broaden horizons on a variety of tangents. At least he does for me. I'm working my way through several Nesbo books ; I collect them in e-book form as they go on sale. I've read the Oslo trilogy and the Bat.

I want to reread Shakespeare's Macbeth because it's been so long that the details are fuzzy. Thanks again for tempting my palate with Nesbo's homage.


message 25: by Glenn (last edited Aug 21, 2018 09:06PM) (new) - added it

Glenn Russell Hey Jeffrey,

I'm well into listening to the audio book. Now I can see clearly why some readers, even Jo Nesbo fans, would give up on the novel - they simply have not read far enough. The action is always brisk but it really kicks into signature high-octane Jo Nesbo gear AFTER the murder of Duncan. WOW! What a difference. I'm listening to the audio book and the story is soo compelling. I'll have my review posted in the next day or so.


Jeffrey Keeten Shelley wrote: "More people should read Shakespeare as his work seems to broaden horizons on a variety of tangents. At least he does for me. I'm working my way through several Nesbo books ; I collect them in e-boo..."

I like pretty much everything Macbeth. These Hogarth books give me an opportunity to reread and review Shakespeare and then see how these modern writers interpret the story. All wonderful!


Jeffrey Keeten Glenn wrote: "Hey Jeffrey,

I'm well into listening to the audio book. Now I can see clearly why some readers, even Jo Nesbo fans, would give up on the novel - they simply have not read far enough. The action is..."


I was enthralled from beginning to end, but I could see how Nesbo's normal readers might be impatient for the plot to explode. Great review Glenn! I really hope we can convince more people to read this wonderful interpretation of Shakespeare's classic.


message 28: by John (new) - added it

John Sullivan I have just started and struggling with it - maybe it’s because I don’t know Macbeth?
Should I read Macbeth and come back to this?
or does it become clearer as I progress?
I like Nesbo but usually gripped by now 😭


message 29: by Glenn (new) - added it

Glenn Russell John wrote: "I have just started and struggling with it - maybe it’s because I don’t know Macbeth?
Should I read Macbeth and come back to this?
or does it become clearer as I progress?
I like Nesbo but usually ..."


Hey John,
I trust Jeffrey wouldn't mind my taking a stab re your questions.

Like yourself, I'm a big Jo Nesbo fan and have been hooked on his books from the first chapter. With his Macbeth I was not since, in my judgement, the signature Nesbo pulse and action doesn't kick in until after the murder of Duncan 100 pages in (Chapter 10). I said as much in my review. Link: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...

In my judgement one doesn't have to have read the Shakespeare play although this would be ideal. Rather, a general familiarity via the Wiki article will do just find. Link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macbeth


Jeffrey Keeten John wrote: "I have just started and struggling with it - maybe it’s because I don’t know Macbeth?
Should I read Macbeth and come back to this?
or does it become clearer as I progress?
I like Nesbo but usually ..."


I agree with all that Glenn says John. I certainly think part of the joy of reading this book is to know the characters from the play well enough to see how cleverly Nesbo has recreated them. I've read the play a couple of times, seen the play performed, and watched several Macbeth movies so my knowledge of the source material is pertty deep. (I'm a fan boy of Macbeth material.) If there isn't enough action for you Glenn's demarcation line of 100 pages is probably a good one to shoot for.


Jeffrey Keeten Glenn wrote: "John wrote: "I have just started and struggling with it - maybe it’s because I don’t know Macbeth?
Should I read Macbeth and come back to this?
or does it become clearer as I progress?
I like Nesbo..."


Thanks Glenn!


Keruonedz Your review is written better than the book! :D


Jeffrey Keeten Keruonedz wrote: "Your review is written better than the book! :D"

Thank you kind sir, but I must respectfully disagree with you . :-)


Paula K Love your review for this brilliant book, Jeffrey!


Jeffrey Keeten Thanks Paula!


Jeffrey Keeten Thanks Leslie!


Naseem Ambar Haidry Great review. I would recommend you to watch Maqbool (2003), an Indian cinematic adaptation of Macbeth. Personally, I feel it's right up there with the finest adaptations of the play.


Jeffrey Keeten Naseem Ambar wrote: "Great review. I would recommend you to watch Maqbool (2003), an Indian cinematic adaptation of Macbeth. Personally, I feel it's right up there with the finest adaptations of the play."

Thanks Naseem! I will definitely watch it if I can find it on youtube. That sounds like a great adaptation.


message 39: by ElementalDragon (new)

ElementalDragon great review


message 40: by Margot (new) - added it

Margot Meanders Oh, this is intriguing. I was going to start Nesbo with the Harry Hole series but this being related to Macbeth immediately caught my attention! Thanks for the review!


Jeffrey Keeten Oscar Liu wrote: "great review"

Thanks Oscar!


Jeffrey Keeten Margot wrote: "Oh, this is intriguing. I was going to start Nesbo with the Harry Hole series but this being related to Macbeth immediately caught my attention! Thanks for the review!"

You are most welcome! I'm a huge fan of the play so I was so pleased they selected Nesbo for the retelling. A most unexpected surprise.


Jeffrey Keeten T for Tongue-Tied wrote: "As an old Nesbø fan, I have been itching to read it but now the delicate nature of that itch has turned into a proper eczematous frenzy! As always, a big thank you, Jeffrey :)"

You are most welcome! I hope you enjoy this one. It made me want to pull out my DVD copy of the Sam Worthington version of Macbeth...so fun.


message 44: by Branka (new)

Branka Todoric Jo Nesbo Macbeth the book has too many things going on not my cup of tea Stick to the main plot. Who really killed the police comissioner, Krnneth?


message 45: by Branka (new)

Branka Todoric I am aware of the Shakespeare's version of Macbeth and the fact that he starts to hallucinate after he murders his brother, but the book draggs on and on about this fact and then starts about the decay of the city and mafia murders and Mcbeth the detective in the book has no guts to do anything about Banquo's murder. In fact he did it.


message 46: by Branka (new)

Branka Todoric By the time one approaches the end of the book one loses the point of the main plot. Too much in one book. This could have been a sequel.


Jeffrey Keeten Branka wrote: "Jo Nesbo Macbeth the book has too many things going on not my cup of tea Stick to the main plot. Who really killed the police comissioner, Krnneth?"

Well I'm sorry it wasn't your cup of tea Branka. It was certainly mine. I loved it.


Jeffrey Keeten Branka wrote: "I am aware of the Shakespeare's version of Macbeth and the fact that he starts to hallucinate after he murders his brother, but the book draggs on and on about this fact and then starts about the d..."

If you are aware, but haven't read the original Macbeth than why did you read this? Of course you would have enjoyed the book more if you'd read the original version.


Jeffrey Keeten Branka wrote: "By the time one approaches the end of the book one loses the point of the main plot. Too much in one book. This could have been a sequel."

I disagree. I was able to keep track of the main plot and the subplots without any issues. I don't like linear books though, but I know younger readers prefer their books easier to follow.


TheBookWarren What an absolute cracker of a review mate, you’ve convinces me that this is an experimental experience well worthwhile!


« previous 1
back to top