Trish's Reviews > TrumpNation: The Art of Being The Donald

TrumpNation by Timothy L. O'Brien
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
1826682
Tim O'Brien restored my sense of humor. O'Brien was sued by the Donald over the reporting in this book, twice, but if anything, O'Brien makes the Donald look bombastic rather than purposely evil. At first I was disconcerted by the breezy style, but by the middle I understood that the style matched the subject matter.

I was laughing by the time O’Brien tells us about the fight headlined daily in the New York papers between developer Trump and Mayor Koch in the 1980s. I got to the point where I was thinking, like Trump’s wives, “That’s just Donald. He does it to everybody.” He is a braggart and a smooth-talking operator. Everyone knows he is lying, but because no one takes him seriously, what he says doesn’t matter.

But that’s all over now. Now people must take him seriously, and it is difficult to change early impressions. The only thing we do know is that among the powerful, nearly everyone is waiting for him to trip up and hang himself. No one, except perhaps Giuliani, has any loyalty to this guy. After all, Trump has insulted them, lorded over them, sued them even. He won the election, yes, but if he blows it, they will dump him faster than Brutus stabbed Caesar.

Now, to this book. It was initially published in October of 2005, long before politicos around the nation were speaking of Trump in the same breath as Bush, Romney, and Obama. Their worlds did not overlap. A second edition of the book was published June 2016 with a new Introduction (described here in the Washington Post) which should give you some idea of O’Brien’s writing style and attitudes towards the Don.

The thing that I began to warm to in O’Brien’s telling is that this could be perceived as funny. Donald is a gad-dang charlatan, for cripes’ sake. Everyone knows that, especially the dour-faced Republicans who opposed him during the campaign. And they are all lawyers. Donald has so much objectionable, actionable, lying behaviors behind--and presumably ahead--of him that they can take him down at any time they decide to put their little minds to the task. It just depends how long they can keep him on their leash. This has nothing to do with “popular opinion.” That pleasantry will go right out the window when the politicos decide enough is enough. Brutus and Caesar.

Anyway, O'Brien's telling is a hoot. I first read David Cay Johnston’s The Making of Donald Trump which allowed me to relax into this more casual history. Both books have great stories about Trump in conflict with one powerful billionaire after another. I particularly liked the story about Trump so admiring the Plaza Hotel that he bought it despite its flaws at a price which began to suck his wallet dry.
"This isn’t just a building, it’s the ultimate work of art," Donald said of his hotel. "I was in love with it…I tore myself up to get the Plaza."
It’s nice to know there is some sentiment in the guy, even if it is only for a building and not for the blond bombshells he married to amuse himself and dazzle us. Somewhere along the time O’Brien recalls the testimony from Steve Wynn, Las Vegas developer, discussing Trump(1) do I begin to see that Trump’s election is a fluke, and that he is hanging again by his toenails to this high bar he has managed, by luck and bravado, to scale. But there isn’t much underneath him, and it is just a matter of time before the Washington establishment declares “This emperor has NO clothes!”

Endlessly amusing if one can detach the real-world implications of Donald Trump as President of the United States, this book should be required reading for those too distressed to listen to news since the election. It is a reality inoculation to stave off despair. We knew we had a lot of work to do to repair the political system. Now we have no choice. It is not a question of “if” or “when.” The answer will have to be “now.” Be prepared to become involved.

(1)Steve Wynn on Donald Trump:
"No sane or rational guy would respond to Trump," Wynn responded. "His statements to people like you, whether they concern us or our projects, or our motivations, or his own reality, or his own future, or his own present, you have seen over the years have no relation to truth or fact. And if you need me to remind you that, we’re both in trouble. He’s a fool."


This is featured as a Goodreads giveaway for another 24 hours or so. Sign up! You may want something to laugh through over Christmas vacation, before rolling up your sleeves to get to work next year putting some structures in place when he goes down. Think positively.
66 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read TrumpNation.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

November 14, 2016 – Shelved as: to-read
November 14, 2016 – Shelved
November 20, 2016 – Started Reading
November 20, 2016 – Shelved as: america
November 20, 2016 – Shelved as: biography
November 20, 2016 – Shelved as: business
November 20, 2016 – Shelved as: history
November 20, 2016 – Shelved as: journalism
November 20, 2016 – Shelved as: mythology
November 20, 2016 – Shelved as: nonfiction
November 20, 2016 – Shelved as: politics
November 20, 2016 – Shelved as: psychology
November 20, 2016 – Shelved as: something-completely-new
November 20, 2016 – Shelved as: true-crime
November 21, 2016 –
page 54
18.75% "Oh, I don't know about this. It seems sensational & though informative about Fred Trump's real estate career & Donald's beginning, isn't giving me much about the man...unless there really isn't much to the man. We see business dealings. Those can be scrounged from newspaper articles. What makes the man tick? I don't like the answers that come to everyone's lips first. But I need to listen because they may be right."
December 2, 2016 –
page 107
37.15% "I am enjoying this much more after reading The Making of Donald Trump by David Cay Johnston. O'Brien wrote this originally in 2004, so he is basically laughing at the chicanery demonstrated. His description of the Koch-Trump rivalry that played out in 1980's headlines is masterful. And the description of the Plaza Hotel purchase is not to be missed."
December 3, 2016 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-24 of 24 (24 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Christy (new)

Christy Hammer You use the term "charlatan" in both of these excellent reviews of Don the Con. He is the classical "bullshit artist", and I've waited for this term to be used about him, but maybe it's too crass.


Trish I'm not sure "artist" in any way describes the man, though some folks swoon over his erections (buildings, that is).


message 3: by Mike (new)

Mike i think 'bombastic rather than purposefully evil' is probably right. he's sort of like a dog with rabies- oblivious to the destruction he leaves in his wake.

and it's a good point that there are certain aspects of his personality that are actually amusing. it was great fun to watch him debate and take down stiffs like jeb bush, for example. but that's also part of the danger, i think- his cartoonish personality leads people to consistently underestimate him.


Trish Mike wrote: "his cartoonish personality leads people to consistently underestimate him...."

Yes, I see your point, but when you hear what he has been saying for thirty or forty years, you realize there is not much depth to this man. We may underestimate his effect on the electorate, but not so much the man. He is a citizen, and should have the rights and responsibilities of a citizen. But a leader? I'm sorry, I don't see it.


message 5: by Mike (last edited Dec 03, 2016 02:26PM) (new)

Mike i agree with you- i didn't mean to suggest that i think he has any depth. if anything, i think people overestimate that. i did, at first. i would wonder, 'what does he really think, what does he really believe?' but i don't think there is anything more than what we see.

i meant, as you say, the uncanny effect he apparently has on people- kind of like hitler, mussolini and l. ron hubbard. and that his cartoonish personality seems to lull some people into the delusion that he's essentially benign.


Trish Mike wrote: " the uncanny effect he apparently has on people... his cartoonish personality seems to lull some people into the delusion that he's essentially benign...."

My guess is that they wish the glitz and glamour meant life was better somewhere...and that they'd like to get there. But that is as much a dream as Trump is a leader. Beyond a certain point, money can't mask the real task of living with meaning. I'm surprised so many folks fell for it. Wishing don't make anything so.

The folks who wish they were where Trump is now should perhaps think that Mar-a-Lago is one of the first places that will be underwater in 20 years or less. My understanding is that if Trump can deny climate change long enough he can get the government to bail him out, pay him back, whatever...so that he can preserve his foolish investment dollars. But really, we're going to need everyone pulling in the same direction to out-swim this.

Funny, but maybe not so much.


message 7: by Betsy (last edited Dec 04, 2016 03:11AM) (new)

Betsy Robinson Brilliant review. This helps. Thanks, Trish--again. (I'm going to share this review on Facebook--it's so helpful to laugh or even think about laughing right now.)


Trish Of course, we must take into consideration the continuing downside of Republicans in control. But sometimes the weight of it all is too much to bear alone.


message 9: by Ken (new)

Ken At least we have the lovely SNL satires (which, gloriously enough, get under his thin, dish-it-out-but-can't-take-it skin).


message 10: by Julie (new)

Julie Nice review, Trish. At first, I thought I was seeing double (because I usually read reviews in the morning, with my coffee) and thought the caffeine hadn't kicked in yet. : ) Yes, you've actually read two Trump books, back to back. Brave woman! As much as I enjoyed your reviews, I don't think I can read either one of these, because when it came to reviewing them it would mean I'd have to take out my thesaurus for polite words on your charlatan citation. He is more than a little vomit-inducing in my world, and though I have not gone so far as to turn off the telly when he's on, I've certainly tossed things at it, and am afraid I may one day pull an Elvis and be rid of this type of media altogether. Thanks for being the canary in the coal mine for us and lighting the way!


Trish Julie wrote: "though I have not gone so far as to turn off the telly when he's on, I've certainly tossed things at it, and am afraid I may one day pull an Elvis and be rid of this type of media altogether..."

Have reduced my television to three stations after the election. I am horrified at the quality of reporting. The punditry is at least as bad as the man himself. I was sick to my stomach for a month, and feeling so lost I couldn't do much of anything. O'Brien lightened me up. If all is lost, it was before Trump even raised his hairsprayed head. Trump is a symptom. We created him.


message 12: by Christy (last edited Dec 04, 2016 07:08AM) (new)

Christy Hammer So true that a Trump world is hard to face alone. I am also grateful that Trish read and reviewed both of these books. I can only watch PBS calmly right now myself. Consciously, I had a worse month of funk over the death of Gwen Ifill than over Trump... More anger and disgust with the latter.

The media has much culpability with Trump, including letting him rail against the "phantom enemy" of Political Correctness - to solicit scorn from many White rust-belters for people of color, etc. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2...


message 13: by Kim (new)

Kim Berkshire I love the latest, Ken, Alec Baldwin telling Trump he'll stop with the impersonations when Trump releases his taxes. Anyway, still too soon to read a book about Cheeto Jesus. But if/when I do, this will be the one. Thanks for the review Trish.


Trish Kim wrote: "I love the latest, Ken, Alec Baldwin telling Trump he'll stop with the impersonations when Trump releases his taxes. Anyway, still too soon to read a book about Cheeto Jesus. But if/when I do, this..."

Love that, Cheeto Jesus. I also love the SNL sketches. Baldwin has a delivery with panache. Wonder what Capitol Steps did with their program this year. Must check. Bet they were caught off-guard also.


message 15: by Lyn (new)

Lyn Elliott Great review. And it's probably no consolation to you at all that even here in Australia there are many of us who can't bear to watch the Trump segments of the news.


Trish Lyn wrote: "Great review. And it's probably no consolation to you at all that even here in Australia there are many of us who can't bear to watch the Trump segments of the news."

Today the NYT had a story about Austria's recent election defeating the populist candidate and I read it as "Australia." I was shocked to think you all were in the middle of that & I didn't know. Well, that is still in your future, but Austria, so far, escaped the plague. I fear for France, Germany. They say Hungary is ready to jump into populist arms, but the European former Soviet satellites are all more leftist. I do believe China will jockey to stave off instability & take advantage of the uncertainty. It's only natural. Russia...can go hang. All at a time when we are going to need our wits about us.


message 17: by Christy (last edited Dec 04, 2016 03:48PM) (new)

Christy Hammer Maybe you saw that Joy Reid (US political commentator) twittered yesterday that "the great irony is that the ethnonationalist, populist wave sweeping Europe and the U.S. is installing oligarchies, not populists." Maybe this has always happened and some of us never noticed? Suddenly Trump reminded me of dictators like Peron in Argentina.


message 18: by Carol (new)

Carol At least this one wasn't pure punishment. Enjoyed this review.


message 19: by Warwick (new)

Warwick This is an encouraging review and I hope you're right. But even if you are, the potential is there for him to do extraordinary damage before he is somehow removed. I am still trying to get my head around the prospect of a UN security council that could include May, Trump, Putin and Le Pen. I must admit, it's not easy to laugh.


Trish Warwick wrote: "This is an encouraging review and I hope you're right. But even if you are, the potential is there for him to do extraordinary damage before he is somehow removed. I am still trying to get my head ..."

I know. Perhaps I am just giddy. It all seems like a nightmare. Just remember Washington is made up of an enormous bureaucracy. Most times we hate the dip-drip-drip slowness of policy implementation, but we may come to appreciate how hard it is to accomplish anything without the bulk of the bureaucracy behind one.


Trish Ken wrote: "At least we have the lovely SNL satires (which, gloriously enough, get under his thin, dish-it-out-but-can't-take-it skin)."

Have been thinking about this. In the winter of 2015-16, Trump was the brunt of a Comedy Central roasting. It was remarkably crude, filled with sexual innuendo & gesture by theatre folk of every stripe. Trump is a showman. He likes & admires showmen. It is so weird to see him coming down hard on comedians. His group, until he decided he wanted to be president, was filled with celebrities, the crooked, and the mobbed-up. Who is he kidding now? But I love Baldwin's response: "I'll quit when you release your taxes." That ought to shut Trump up.


message 22: by Ken (new)

Ken Auditors, don't you know. Auditors.


message 23: by Kim (new)

Kim Berkshire Christy, I love Joy Reid and also follow her on Twitter. Don't think it was a coincidence that, in so many of his rallies, Trump was channeling Mussolini. And as far as Peron goes, ''Don't Cry For Me...America.''
When I hear people say, ''we survived the Bush years,'' well, not sure all the families that lost servicemen and women in all our wars feel the same way.


Trish Kim wrote: "Christy, I love Joy Reid and also follow her on Twitter. Don't think it was a coincidence that, in so many of his rallies, Trump was channeling Mussolini. And as far as Peron goes, ''Don't Cry For ..."

I never heard of Joy Reid. I will look for her. If Trump and the Republicans are able to put their ideas into effect, I think it could be extremely damaging to the concept of thoughtfulness among the populace. But one never knows what will come. Perhaps the polarization will be an impetus to some to make greater strides in the direction they wish to go. Perhaps a great leader will emerge.


back to top