What do you think?
Rate this book
256 pages, Paperback
First published March 5, 2019
“And here in Fallen Mountains, you don’t really get to unhitch yourself from your past.”
“I like that about you. You see the best in people. You’ve got grace for them, I should say. You forgive.”
Every day of his life, he was paying the price for their selfishness, and he’d had enough.
CW: trapping, hunting and gutting animals, adultery, child abuse and neglect, grief, mental illness and severe bullying
The past was never dead; it was never past. But it didn't have to own you, either. It didn't have to be all you were.
For me it's probably the hardest to write reviews for books, that were in my opinion just - meh - average. You know, when nothing is particularly wrong with a story, but it just didn't fully grab you for one reason or another? Unfortunately that's the case with Fallen Mountains, I was really looking forward to reading.
In the fictional rural small town of Fallen Mountains in Western Pennsylvania, USA sheriff Red (the only law enforcement officer in this little town) is on the verge of retirement after over twenty years on the job, when Transom Schultz goes missing. At first he handles it as a rather annoying inconvenience, that will hopefully resolve itself quickly, because Transom is known for packing up his stuff and leaving without a word. But soon Red must acknowledge that it's different this time: Transom was finally settling down as he just proposed to his girlfriend, he also left behind his car and all of his papers. Red opens up the investigation and while he goes around, retracing Transom's last known steps, he worries about a secret he kept for over a decade and wonders, if it finally came back to haunt him. Why hadn't he handed in his retirement resignation letter just one day sooner?
The story is told in alternating Before and After chapters, following a handful of characters, which I initially really enjoyed. Unfortunately there were a lot of flashback scenes in order to give some context to the various relationships in either chapters that I constantly had to make sure what kind of chapter I currently was reading. At times these passages also felt a little bit like info-dumps.
I also found the characters to be rather one dimensional and repetitive. The sheriff who's embarrassed and reluctant to investigate the people he knew since their childhood. Chase, Transom's childhood best friend, who's constantly asking himself how Transom could have been so selfish, while recalling moment after moment from the past, where everybody (including himself) was (and still is) enabling this kind of behaviour. Laney, also a childhood friend of Chase and Transom, who's sole purpose was to be the center of a love triangle. Her portrayal irritated me the most, because she really didn't have anything other to add to the story other than lamenting about how Chase couldn't find out about her and Transom until the very end. Possum, Laney's cousin and Transom's bullying victim with anger issues.
When I reached the second half and figured out, who had what kind of role within the story, this book couldn't hold my interest for more than a few pages at a time. What kept me going was the mystery itself, which heavily relied on Transom's awful nature. Literally everyone could have had a good reason to want him gone, therefore I didn't see the ending coming and I do really appreciate it, because Kimi Cunningham Grant didn't make a big spectacle out of it, it just kind of is what it is? I really like that.
Overall this is a decent enough mystery but unfortunately something I probably won't remember much off in a couple of weeks. Looking at all the 4-and-5-star ratings, I'm clearly in the minority with my opinion, so I'd say go for it, if you are interested in small towns full of secrets which most likely could have been resolved a long time ago, if only the people would talk to one another. Thinking about it, a more accurate introductory quote would have been:
The words just wouldn't come out.
Thank you to NetGalley and Amberjack Publishing for giving me the opportunity to read this in exchange for an honest review. The quotes are taken from an eARC and may be edited before publication. Sorry I didn't quite like it.