What do you think?
Rate this book
Lady Evelyn Mystery #3
The Study of Silence
Lady Evelyn Carlisle has returned home to England, where she is completing her degree at St. Hugh's, a women's college in Oxford. Her days are spent poring over ancient texts and rushing to tutorials. All is well until a fateful morning, when her peaceful student life is turned on its head. Stumbling upon the gruesome killing of someone she thought she knew, Evelyn is plunged into a murder investigation once more, much to the chagrin of her friends and family, as well as the intriguing Detective Lucas Stanton. The dreaming spires of Oxford begin to appear decidedly less romantic as she gathers clues, and learns far more than she ever wished to know about the darkness lurking beyond the polished veneer. Can she solve the crime before the killer strikes once more, this time to Evelyn's own detriment?
448 pages, Paperback
First published February 27, 2018
About the author
Malia Zaidi
7 books631 followersHello and thanks for stopping by!
I am the author of the Lady Evelyn Mystery series and an avid reader, always happy to discover new books to add to my toppling pile:-)
Check out my blog, The Princess and the Pen: https://maliayz.wixsite.com/princessa...
or get in touch here:
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/maliazaidi/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Malia-Zaidi-...
Twitter: https://twitter.com/MaliaZaidi
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 25 of 25 reviews
July 30, 2022
The Study of Silence is the third book in the 'Lady Evelyn Mystery' series written by Malia Zaidi. A cross between historical fiction and a cozy mystery, readers will find themselves whisked away to a time nearly a century ago when life was quite different. Solving murders was more complicated without the internet, cell phones, and other modern technology. Lady Evelyn must rely on her strong sense of intellect and intuition, and even then, people weren't as direct as they are today.
In this installment, Lady Evelyn has returned to England with Daniel to complete the next phase of her education. While taking classes at a local women's college, and living in a house with several other young ladies, she struggles to decide her future. It's too soon to marry Daniel, and she wants a different kind of life than tradition. Unfortunately, she's born many years too soon for what she wants (and deserves). Transitioning back to the lifestyle of an unmarried English girl is made easier when her cousin, Briony, and her four children, also return from Crete. As does a murder that happens the morning after Evelyn attends a party at another professor's home. Who killed the man? While it shouldn't matter to her, it does... so Evelyn does her best to search for the criminal while getting involved in all sorts of situations at her boardinghouse, with her missing niece, with some family matters, and finally, the actual murder.
Zaidi's writing style and tone will absolutely make you feel like it's the 1920s. Between her vivid descriptions, on-point dialog and tone, and slow yet methodical approach to solving the crime, readers can sit back and just let things unravel. It's not a suspenseful hunt-down-the-killer novel. It's a conversational approach to learning what you can and theorizing options, then looking for clues. As much as it is about the murder, it's also about how a woman lived in the 1920s. Zaidi admits to taking a few liberties to make the story-line work better (totally okay with me!), but nonetheless, it was still a harsh life at the time. Zaidi navigates you down that path with ease, letting readers soak in the painful pressures on a woman in her 20s -- you must get married, you must not do anything bad, you must look innocent at all times! Yikes... how is that even possible?
Silence is key in this book. The reasons for the murder unfold with each chapter, and you'll never guess the killer or the reason why. It was buried too well, but in some ways, it was also quite obvious. That's the sign of a smart author -- it's believable yet you will be shocked. Kudos to Zaidi for bringing out the best in Lady Evelyn. I've purchased the fourth book in the series which recently came out this year. I'll be reading it next month, so I'm fully caught up in this excellent series.
In this installment, Lady Evelyn has returned to England with Daniel to complete the next phase of her education. While taking classes at a local women's college, and living in a house with several other young ladies, she struggles to decide her future. It's too soon to marry Daniel, and she wants a different kind of life than tradition. Unfortunately, she's born many years too soon for what she wants (and deserves). Transitioning back to the lifestyle of an unmarried English girl is made easier when her cousin, Briony, and her four children, also return from Crete. As does a murder that happens the morning after Evelyn attends a party at another professor's home. Who killed the man? While it shouldn't matter to her, it does... so Evelyn does her best to search for the criminal while getting involved in all sorts of situations at her boardinghouse, with her missing niece, with some family matters, and finally, the actual murder.
Zaidi's writing style and tone will absolutely make you feel like it's the 1920s. Between her vivid descriptions, on-point dialog and tone, and slow yet methodical approach to solving the crime, readers can sit back and just let things unravel. It's not a suspenseful hunt-down-the-killer novel. It's a conversational approach to learning what you can and theorizing options, then looking for clues. As much as it is about the murder, it's also about how a woman lived in the 1920s. Zaidi admits to taking a few liberties to make the story-line work better (totally okay with me!), but nonetheless, it was still a harsh life at the time. Zaidi navigates you down that path with ease, letting readers soak in the painful pressures on a woman in her 20s -- you must get married, you must not do anything bad, you must look innocent at all times! Yikes... how is that even possible?
Silence is key in this book. The reasons for the murder unfold with each chapter, and you'll never guess the killer or the reason why. It was buried too well, but in some ways, it was also quite obvious. That's the sign of a smart author -- it's believable yet you will be shocked. Kudos to Zaidi for bringing out the best in Lady Evelyn. I've purchased the fourth book in the series which recently came out this year. I'll be reading it next month, so I'm fully caught up in this excellent series.
February 27, 2018
Forgive my bias, but I am rather fond of this one:-)
July 7, 2018
“I cannot quite imagine her—slender, fearful girl that she is—ramming a knife into a beating heart, not once, but repeatedly. The very thought brings a taste of bile to my throat and I take an unwilling sip of milky brew, privately wishing for a drop of something stronger. I am getting nowhere”.
Oh but you are getting somewhere Lady Carlisle...you always do ..
.....we love your tenacity!!
Even Inspector Stanton wouldn’t have ‘Evelyn’ any other way!!!
Sure he thinks she meddles in everyone’s affairs - but
deep down he admires the heck of of her as we all do!
No fun to solve a mystery without her. 🙂!
This is the third book in a *wonderful* series-
In past novels -Lady Carlisle felt at home in Greece with her cousin Briony - while solving a mystery -
In France she had Daniel-
Now in London she is away from those who love her. Evelyn is scholar of ancient times ... reading The Illiad’...and other literary texts getting her degree in literature at Oxford... She’s a little lonely- but isn’t that to be expected with growth?
... she loves Daniel...but women were just beginning to have an opportunity to University life.... not something Evelyn wanted to sacrifice.
Lots of social changes was happening for women in the 1920’s. It wasn’t called the Rolling 20’s for no reason.
Note to Malia...
I was thinking of where I’d love to see another book go..
I’d love to see Lady Carlisle choose marriage but not children... and have a career.
Our daughter is getting married next month. She’s a strong independent woman - successfully doing well in her career- clear she doesn’t want children. ...
I think many young couples are making this choice not to have kids ...yet still have a life love partner.
So... if you write ‘that’ book... my eyes are wide open with interest.
Thank You Malia - author - and long time friend on Goodreads to many of us on this site - is a TERRIFIC STORYTELLER!!!
All of her books can be found on Kindle unlimited— A bargain!!! Highly recommended ‘any’ or all of them.
Oh but you are getting somewhere Lady Carlisle...you always do ..
.....we love your tenacity!!
Even Inspector Stanton wouldn’t have ‘Evelyn’ any other way!!!
Sure he thinks she meddles in everyone’s affairs - but
deep down he admires the heck of of her as we all do!
No fun to solve a mystery without her. 🙂!
This is the third book in a *wonderful* series-
In past novels -Lady Carlisle felt at home in Greece with her cousin Briony - while solving a mystery -
In France she had Daniel-
Now in London she is away from those who love her. Evelyn is scholar of ancient times ... reading The Illiad’...and other literary texts getting her degree in literature at Oxford... She’s a little lonely- but isn’t that to be expected with growth?
... she loves Daniel...but women were just beginning to have an opportunity to University life.... not something Evelyn wanted to sacrifice.
Lots of social changes was happening for women in the 1920’s. It wasn’t called the Rolling 20’s for no reason.
Note to Malia...
I was thinking of where I’d love to see another book go..
I’d love to see Lady Carlisle choose marriage but not children... and have a career.
Our daughter is getting married next month. She’s a strong independent woman - successfully doing well in her career- clear she doesn’t want children. ...
I think many young couples are making this choice not to have kids ...yet still have a life love partner.
So... if you write ‘that’ book... my eyes are wide open with interest.
Thank You Malia - author - and long time friend on Goodreads to many of us on this site - is a TERRIFIC STORYTELLER!!!
All of her books can be found on Kindle unlimited— A bargain!!! Highly recommended ‘any’ or all of them.
August 31, 2022
My wife didn’t like this one as much as the previous books in this series but I have no idea why (well, maybe a small idea, but I digress) as I enjoyed this one more than the others.
Lady Evie is back in England for this book, her home turf (and mine… well sort of; I am British but this book is set in Oxford and, to quote Bowie, I Have Not Been To Oxford Town) and is struggling to reconnect with family and her previously abandoned studies.
Of course, it’s not long before she finds herself entangled in another murder and her amateur sleuthing tendencies jump to the fore once again.
The book is a lot of fun with well-drawn characters and the Oxford setting really comes alive in the author’s hands. Evie is still a bit too fond of navel-gazing for my liking but I think I must be getting used to it, as it didn’t bother me as much this time around.
On to the next one!
Lady Evie is back in England for this book, her home turf (and mine… well sort of; I am British but this book is set in Oxford and, to quote Bowie, I Have Not Been To Oxford Town) and is struggling to reconnect with family and her previously abandoned studies.
Of course, it’s not long before she finds herself entangled in another murder and her amateur sleuthing tendencies jump to the fore once again.
The book is a lot of fun with well-drawn characters and the Oxford setting really comes alive in the author’s hands. Evie is still a bit too fond of navel-gazing for my liking but I think I must be getting used to it, as it didn’t bother me as much this time around.
On to the next one!
June 9, 2019
Lady Evelyn is studying at Oxford when one of her professors is murdered and she discovers the body. She’d briefly met the detective in charge of the case, Stanton, previously and obviously the book follows as she takes up the mantle of amateur sleuth and investigates alongside him.
This is the third book which has featured Lady Evelyn and, as I haven’t read the first two in the series, I have missed some of the back story of the characters. I didn't have any trouble picking up on who was who but it did make me less inclined to care about the characters from the past books. Evelyn’s cousin Briony and her family's scenes were boring. Daniel, Lady Evelyn’s gentleman friend, and his family/work woes were also dull as dishwater. I found it annoying too that nothing was resolved with either Daniel or Briony’s sub plots. Obviously Zaidi is planning on using them for the next book in the series but I thought there was far too many chapters dedicated to them in The Study of Silence for just a 'taste of things to come'.
Actually the book overall needed some serious editing. It’s long and should have been culled down to a more reasonable length so that it flowed with a better pace. Other than the Briony and Daniel parts, there’s also long winded passages about Evelyn’s parents and aunts which were irrelevant. Each chapter also started with a rambling recap of just how cold it was until the weather featured more than the murder plot, I believe. Add in Evelyn/Zaidi’s habit of going over the same ground in her thinky thoughts and I started to skim.
I will admit I only kept reading to see where the Stanton/Evelyn relationship led. I wish Zaidi had focused on this instead.
It’s difficult to get the right feminist tone in books set in the 20s and I thought Zaidi did a pretty good job in this area. Although, at times, I think she tried too hard and should have just let things flow more organically. The crime, especially, became a little preachy and almost jumped into the ‘me too’ territory before she reined it in.
On a whole, The Study of Silence was okay but unfortunately it didn’t make me want to run out and read the others in the series with any great urgency.
3 out of 5
This is the third book which has featured Lady Evelyn and, as I haven’t read the first two in the series, I have missed some of the back story of the characters. I didn't have any trouble picking up on who was who but it did make me less inclined to care about the characters from the past books. Evelyn’s cousin Briony and her family's scenes were boring. Daniel, Lady Evelyn’s gentleman friend, and his family/work woes were also dull as dishwater. I found it annoying too that nothing was resolved with either Daniel or Briony’s sub plots. Obviously Zaidi is planning on using them for the next book in the series but I thought there was far too many chapters dedicated to them in The Study of Silence for just a 'taste of things to come'.
Actually the book overall needed some serious editing. It’s long and should have been culled down to a more reasonable length so that it flowed with a better pace. Other than the Briony and Daniel parts, there’s also long winded passages about Evelyn’s parents and aunts which were irrelevant. Each chapter also started with a rambling recap of just how cold it was until the weather featured more than the murder plot, I believe. Add in Evelyn/Zaidi’s habit of going over the same ground in her thinky thoughts and I started to skim.
I will admit I only kept reading to see where the Stanton/Evelyn relationship led. I wish Zaidi had focused on this instead.
It’s difficult to get the right feminist tone in books set in the 20s and I thought Zaidi did a pretty good job in this area. Although, at times, I think she tried too hard and should have just let things flow more organically. The crime, especially, became a little preachy and almost jumped into the ‘me too’ territory before she reined it in.
On a whole, The Study of Silence was okay but unfortunately it didn’t make me want to run out and read the others in the series with any great urgency.
3 out of 5
March 8, 2018
Another Lady Evelyn murder mystery adventure set in the sparkling 1920's that provides an engaging murder for her to solve while she ponders the lot of women and faces a little more of her past.
The last book left Evie and Daniel looking to return to England after a long sojourn and several adventures since either of them last touched home soil. Evie has put off Daniel though she knows for certain that she loves him. He has returned to London to attempt reintegrating into his family business with difficulty and life post-war and Evie is in Oxford pursuing an education in the Classics of Literature. Naturally, Evie, being a trouble magnet, stumbles across a murder right in her own sphere and she is off tracking down clues, interfering with the local police, and making herself a target to the terror of Daniel and her family.
What is enjoyable about this series is its wonderful blend of history and mystery, but also ongoing personal story of the main character. Each book tackles a new element of history and in this case, it was women's history and the city of Oxford in the Twenties. Evie is in Oxford attending university so The Study of Silence focuses on women scholars and challenges that face women trying to get an education and what they can do afterward along with the challenges for women who are in a lower social status and have to go without the education and attempt to work without feeling unsafe from abuse in their work environment.
Evie also ponders woman's issues and her future. But, she still has the niggles of her past. Does she sell her family's estate since she can't even bring herself to visit and definitely not live there since her parents died in the fire and hence move on or keep it in the family and force herself to go back? Then, there is her, irrational perhaps, yet very personal fear that she will be tied down if she commits to Daniel though she knows for certain she can trust him not to abuse her trust and she loves him deeply. Is love enough? Can she have love without the bonds of matrimony tying her down without becoming a social pariah and would Daniel even want a half-way commitment like that? She's young, but has so much on her mind and it is all part of an engaging story as she works her way through it all.
Mystery-wise, Evie is as Nancy Drew-ish as ever. She insists she is being sensible and safe and even discreet while the reader and everyone else gets a good laugh because she is anything, but. She's stubborn and bullies the inspector into keeping her involved and she confronts her suspects and witnesses with probing questions. The case teaches her even more about people in that people are complex and not just black or white, but many shades in between when it comes to actions and motives.
I started to get a glimmer as to the killer, but was way off the beam as to why. Just wow! It all made sense and tied together, but most of the time I only had fragments of the truth. This was one of those instances when I know I should be appalled at murder, but the victim was no innocent.
All in all, I was captivated and enjoyed the latest Lady Evelyn mystery. For those who enjoy youthful, intrepid lady detectives in an exciting bygone era, these are for you.
I rec'd this book from Net Galley to read in exchange for an honest review.
The last book left Evie and Daniel looking to return to England after a long sojourn and several adventures since either of them last touched home soil. Evie has put off Daniel though she knows for certain that she loves him. He has returned to London to attempt reintegrating into his family business with difficulty and life post-war and Evie is in Oxford pursuing an education in the Classics of Literature. Naturally, Evie, being a trouble magnet, stumbles across a murder right in her own sphere and she is off tracking down clues, interfering with the local police, and making herself a target to the terror of Daniel and her family.
What is enjoyable about this series is its wonderful blend of history and mystery, but also ongoing personal story of the main character. Each book tackles a new element of history and in this case, it was women's history and the city of Oxford in the Twenties. Evie is in Oxford attending university so The Study of Silence focuses on women scholars and challenges that face women trying to get an education and what they can do afterward along with the challenges for women who are in a lower social status and have to go without the education and attempt to work without feeling unsafe from abuse in their work environment.
Evie also ponders woman's issues and her future. But, she still has the niggles of her past. Does she sell her family's estate since she can't even bring herself to visit and definitely not live there since her parents died in the fire and hence move on or keep it in the family and force herself to go back? Then, there is her, irrational perhaps, yet very personal fear that she will be tied down if she commits to Daniel though she knows for certain she can trust him not to abuse her trust and she loves him deeply. Is love enough? Can she have love without the bonds of matrimony tying her down without becoming a social pariah and would Daniel even want a half-way commitment like that? She's young, but has so much on her mind and it is all part of an engaging story as she works her way through it all.
Mystery-wise, Evie is as Nancy Drew-ish as ever. She insists she is being sensible and safe and even discreet while the reader and everyone else gets a good laugh because she is anything, but. She's stubborn and bullies the inspector into keeping her involved and she confronts her suspects and witnesses with probing questions. The case teaches her even more about people in that people are complex and not just black or white, but many shades in between when it comes to actions and motives.
I started to get a glimmer as to the killer, but was way off the beam as to why. Just wow! It all made sense and tied together, but most of the time I only had fragments of the truth. This was one of those instances when I know I should be appalled at murder, but the victim was no innocent.
All in all, I was captivated and enjoyed the latest Lady Evelyn mystery. For those who enjoy youthful, intrepid lady detectives in an exciting bygone era, these are for you.
I rec'd this book from Net Galley to read in exchange for an honest review.
February 11, 2018
Thank you Net Galley. A delightful cozy mystery that had me looking for the first two books in the series. Perfect for a commute.
April 12, 2019
You can read all my review on Blog - Books Teacup and Reviews
The Study of Silence, third in Lady Evelyn Mystery was cozy historical fiction with new murder mystery and adventure of Evelyn in Oxford. It was about challenge women faced in 1920s, social differences and preconceptions, love, betrayal, abduction, mistreatment and abuse and murder.
Book Proceeded one year after Evelyn’s previous adventure in France, with arrival of Briony’s (Evelyn’s cousin) baby in the world of Evelyn who was currently completing last year of studies in Oxford. And as expected she stumble upon another murder in Oxford. Murder of her Professor Arthur Longfellow just the next day of dinner party she attended at his house. And thus the mystery of solving the murder and finding the culprit began.
Writing was exquisite. Loved the narration of Oxford, St, Hugh’s university, London city, Primrose cottage, and manor of Briony in Chesterton, Daniel’s and Dominic’s large houses was beautiful with minute description that gave the streets and all the houses a vivid picture.
I loved most was, the history around the class difference, etiquettes of Elite class and women’s position during 1920s. It elucidated how war became the catalyst of reducing sex differences, women’s rights, supporting education and independence of women, change in law and inclusion of women among jury and yet on contrary being less lenient to women accused for crime because of preconceptions and women laying less or no trust on police and court when mistreated. Evelyn’s voice was strong, thought provoking and insightful on human nature, prejudice of society and ugliness and beauty of world.
In this book we learn more about Briony’s family, and Daniel’s cousin and his frustrating position in his own company. Aunt Agnes was most surprising by her placid, cheerful and lively demeanor contrary to her rigid, stern Nature. Oh I didn’t expect the reason behind such sudden change. Evelyn encountered some lovely and some not so friendly people in Oxford. Cold, emotionless professor and unlikable classmates, insensitive and taciturn housemate gave her tough time. I never liked Olivia, even after knowing her history. I felt for Lily and Fiona. The past of Mr. Brown, Mrs. Warren, and Evelyn’s friendship with inspector Stanton was engaging.
Daniel was ever so charming gentleman. His concerns regarding Evelyn’s safety and yet giving in to her wishes, not pushing her for marriage and giving her freedom was admirable. Best moment was when he was showing his house that he built and decorated in accordance with Evelyn’s taste. He won my heart right then and there.
It was sweet to see Evelyn’s possessiveness for Daniel. I felt irritated for her denial to prospect of marriage proposal. Like Briony and her stern natured Aunt Agnes, I also think she is silly for not tying this beautiful relationship in strong bond. I understand her wish to give herself time and to decide her future, live independently but declaring engagement before marriage won’t hurt, right? This part of Evelyn’s Nature was complex and beyond comprehension. Anyway, I loved them together as a couple.
Evelyn was inquisitive creature. Smart, kind and empathetic with the same strong conscience but she developed with what she experienced in previous two books. We see a different side of Evelyn in her hometown. I liked her for her bravery and instincts that saved her friends. She was great listener that made people confide to her and unburden their worries.
When it came to mysteries, she was too nosy and reckless than previous books. Even after persistent warning from police and her loved ones, she kept putting herself in danger. This time murderer was one step ahead, watching all her moves even though she was not totally involved in the mystery like previous ones.
First 40% was new character intro, what old one did after previous mysteries, set up of the mystery, and drama related to secondary characters. As soon as I observed Longfellow’s look towards Evelyn, I knew something was not right with this man and then next he is dead. But who did it and why? Evelyn’s monologue and her curious questions matched mine all the time.
Number of suspects was not much. The members present on the morning of murder were questionable and I was surprised no one kept eye on each of them properly and things were assumed based on preconception and there wasn’t proper investigation on the character of Longfellow but I could see why people were unforthcoming after knowing the truth.
Tragedies happened in book were as interesting as Greek tragedies Evelyn was learning. The small dramas of missing Iona, illicit love, betrayal by friend, suicide attempt, watchful eyes in shadow and attack on Evelyn surrounded the main mystery which kept going round in circle until 80% of the book.
Climax was great. Since the discovery of mystery man at doorstep of Longfellow and attack on Evelyn, things started to turn interesting. I was not real shocked by revelation of real culprit but the way it was execute was brilliant. At the end I kept thinking how prologue fit with the story. I went back to it, read again and then I understood how smartly it was connected. End was satisfactory. Loved the epilogue. I hope she has some more sense in next book regarding her relationship.
Overall, it was dramatic cozy murder mystery with engaging history , brilliant plot, developed character and vivid narration. It is best book and series for cozy mystery lovers.
*** Note: I received e-copy of this book from the author via damppebbles blog tours, in exchange for an honest review. ***
The Study of Silence, third in Lady Evelyn Mystery was cozy historical fiction with new murder mystery and adventure of Evelyn in Oxford. It was about challenge women faced in 1920s, social differences and preconceptions, love, betrayal, abduction, mistreatment and abuse and murder.
Book Proceeded one year after Evelyn’s previous adventure in France, with arrival of Briony’s (Evelyn’s cousin) baby in the world of Evelyn who was currently completing last year of studies in Oxford. And as expected she stumble upon another murder in Oxford. Murder of her Professor Arthur Longfellow just the next day of dinner party she attended at his house. And thus the mystery of solving the murder and finding the culprit began.
Writing was exquisite. Loved the narration of Oxford, St, Hugh’s university, London city, Primrose cottage, and manor of Briony in Chesterton, Daniel’s and Dominic’s large houses was beautiful with minute description that gave the streets and all the houses a vivid picture.
I loved most was, the history around the class difference, etiquettes of Elite class and women’s position during 1920s. It elucidated how war became the catalyst of reducing sex differences, women’s rights, supporting education and independence of women, change in law and inclusion of women among jury and yet on contrary being less lenient to women accused for crime because of preconceptions and women laying less or no trust on police and court when mistreated. Evelyn’s voice was strong, thought provoking and insightful on human nature, prejudice of society and ugliness and beauty of world.
In this book we learn more about Briony’s family, and Daniel’s cousin and his frustrating position in his own company. Aunt Agnes was most surprising by her placid, cheerful and lively demeanor contrary to her rigid, stern Nature. Oh I didn’t expect the reason behind such sudden change. Evelyn encountered some lovely and some not so friendly people in Oxford. Cold, emotionless professor and unlikable classmates, insensitive and taciturn housemate gave her tough time. I never liked Olivia, even after knowing her history. I felt for Lily and Fiona. The past of Mr. Brown, Mrs. Warren, and Evelyn’s friendship with inspector Stanton was engaging.
Daniel was ever so charming gentleman. His concerns regarding Evelyn’s safety and yet giving in to her wishes, not pushing her for marriage and giving her freedom was admirable. Best moment was when he was showing his house that he built and decorated in accordance with Evelyn’s taste. He won my heart right then and there.
It was sweet to see Evelyn’s possessiveness for Daniel. I felt irritated for her denial to prospect of marriage proposal. Like Briony and her stern natured Aunt Agnes, I also think she is silly for not tying this beautiful relationship in strong bond. I understand her wish to give herself time and to decide her future, live independently but declaring engagement before marriage won’t hurt, right? This part of Evelyn’s Nature was complex and beyond comprehension. Anyway, I loved them together as a couple.
Evelyn was inquisitive creature. Smart, kind and empathetic with the same strong conscience but she developed with what she experienced in previous two books. We see a different side of Evelyn in her hometown. I liked her for her bravery and instincts that saved her friends. She was great listener that made people confide to her and unburden their worries.
When it came to mysteries, she was too nosy and reckless than previous books. Even after persistent warning from police and her loved ones, she kept putting herself in danger. This time murderer was one step ahead, watching all her moves even though she was not totally involved in the mystery like previous ones.
First 40% was new character intro, what old one did after previous mysteries, set up of the mystery, and drama related to secondary characters. As soon as I observed Longfellow’s look towards Evelyn, I knew something was not right with this man and then next he is dead. But who did it and why? Evelyn’s monologue and her curious questions matched mine all the time.
Number of suspects was not much. The members present on the morning of murder were questionable and I was surprised no one kept eye on each of them properly and things were assumed based on preconception and there wasn’t proper investigation on the character of Longfellow but I could see why people were unforthcoming after knowing the truth.
Tragedies happened in book were as interesting as Greek tragedies Evelyn was learning. The small dramas of missing Iona, illicit love, betrayal by friend, suicide attempt, watchful eyes in shadow and attack on Evelyn surrounded the main mystery which kept going round in circle until 80% of the book.
Climax was great. Since the discovery of mystery man at doorstep of Longfellow and attack on Evelyn, things started to turn interesting. I was not real shocked by revelation of real culprit but the way it was execute was brilliant. At the end I kept thinking how prologue fit with the story. I went back to it, read again and then I understood how smartly it was connected. End was satisfactory. Loved the epilogue. I hope she has some more sense in next book regarding her relationship.
Overall, it was dramatic cozy murder mystery with engaging history , brilliant plot, developed character and vivid narration. It is best book and series for cozy mystery lovers.
*** Note: I received e-copy of this book from the author via damppebbles blog tours, in exchange for an honest review. ***
February 7, 2018
It's 1926 and Lady Evelyn Carlisle has finally returned to England, to complete her degree at St. Hugh's, Oxford. Following an end of term dinner party the body of one of the tutor's is found the next morning.
As Evelyn discovered the body she feels the need to investigate the murder, hoping to receive the help of Detective Stanton who she had previously rescued.
An enjoyable, gently paced, character driven mystery which takes its time to resolve.
A NetGalley Book
As Evelyn discovered the body she feels the need to investigate the murder, hoping to receive the help of Detective Stanton who she had previously rescued.
An enjoyable, gently paced, character driven mystery which takes its time to resolve.
A NetGalley Book
March 30, 2018
Overall I really enjoyed this entertaining story. I liked the plot twists and turns. I loved Daniel and the detective inspector. The plot had several subplots that keep you on your toes and guessing and you never really truly know who killed Longfellow until the very end and even than it is surprising.
We see so many stories evolve in this mystery. We have the story of Evelyn and her journey in finding herself and her future. How she keeps Daniel at a distance out of fear and needs to figure out where he figures in her future. We have her studies and where she wants to take them. We have the stories of her family and what is going on in their lives. We have Evelyn’s curiosity and how it has her play a role in wanting to solve who killed Longfellow and why.
We have the story of the Warren’s and how they fit in the mystery but also how they are in the life of Evelyn, Olivia and Lucy. We have the story of Lucy and her betrayals. The story of Olivia and who she is really and where her future brings her.
We get the story of Longfellow and what kind of person he was. He wasn’t a great guy although his outward appearance to others says otherwise. So many would want to kill him for all he did.
We have the story of the detective inspector and how he goes about solving the murder. We see how he fits into Evelyn figuring out her place in the future as well.
I enjoyed the plot, the storyline and loved the characters. At times Evelyn got to me but mainly because of how she treated Daniel. It felt like she was toying with him and that bothered me. Other than that she was inquisitive and entertaining. The story keeps you on your toes. Where I had a issue and others may not is all the details that to me weren’t needed. I understand some background information and attention to detail but at times there was too much. It didn’t detract from the story but did drag it a little for me. Again others may not have that issue but for me it was because I was really into the mystery and suspects and would get distracted with a different field of inquiry or lots of details not needed for me but again others may want it. Other than that I thoroughly enjoyed the story and all its twists, turns and secrets it revealed while we got a glimpse into the character’s lives and where they were going.
We see so many stories evolve in this mystery. We have the story of Evelyn and her journey in finding herself and her future. How she keeps Daniel at a distance out of fear and needs to figure out where he figures in her future. We have her studies and where she wants to take them. We have the stories of her family and what is going on in their lives. We have Evelyn’s curiosity and how it has her play a role in wanting to solve who killed Longfellow and why.
We have the story of the Warren’s and how they fit in the mystery but also how they are in the life of Evelyn, Olivia and Lucy. We have the story of Lucy and her betrayals. The story of Olivia and who she is really and where her future brings her.
We get the story of Longfellow and what kind of person he was. He wasn’t a great guy although his outward appearance to others says otherwise. So many would want to kill him for all he did.
We have the story of the detective inspector and how he goes about solving the murder. We see how he fits into Evelyn figuring out her place in the future as well.
I enjoyed the plot, the storyline and loved the characters. At times Evelyn got to me but mainly because of how she treated Daniel. It felt like she was toying with him and that bothered me. Other than that she was inquisitive and entertaining. The story keeps you on your toes. Where I had a issue and others may not is all the details that to me weren’t needed. I understand some background information and attention to detail but at times there was too much. It didn’t detract from the story but did drag it a little for me. Again others may not have that issue but for me it was because I was really into the mystery and suspects and would get distracted with a different field of inquiry or lots of details not needed for me but again others may want it. Other than that I thoroughly enjoyed the story and all its twists, turns and secrets it revealed while we got a glimpse into the character’s lives and where they were going.
March 25, 2018
The Study of Silence is baffles me as to what the true plot is. Though, it is good read. I know there a murder in the book. Why, the person is murdered, you will not by no mean until the end of the book.
I know the story is somewhat told in a third person i believe anyway. I was wondering if was more about human nature or if the story was more set to be about Evelyn. Why someone is after her when she not does much to find out. Evelyn seems to get sucked into the murder and danger accidentally.
I do enjoy the fact that we learn about women's rights a bit during England era though this book. The story is set in the era of 1926 England. We experience or learn about Oxford and that time period and customs. That part of the story give the author a swell of job.
She touches a bit of things that might go one during this time that we do not like in our modern day time. The cause of this murder and the unlikely will be surprise of the reason for it. Was the professor living a double life or a secret life. Who is the murderer? To find out you will have to read the book.
I know the story is somewhat told in a third person i believe anyway. I was wondering if was more about human nature or if the story was more set to be about Evelyn. Why someone is after her when she not does much to find out. Evelyn seems to get sucked into the murder and danger accidentally.
I do enjoy the fact that we learn about women's rights a bit during England era though this book. The story is set in the era of 1926 England. We experience or learn about Oxford and that time period and customs. That part of the story give the author a swell of job.
She touches a bit of things that might go one during this time that we do not like in our modern day time. The cause of this murder and the unlikely will be surprise of the reason for it. Was the professor living a double life or a secret life. Who is the murderer? To find out you will have to read the book.
March 3, 2018
A suitably dark English noir, country murder mystery. While this reads perfectly fine as a stand alone, I think this series is best enjoyed in sequence.
It deals with dark topics that are as timely today as they were in the 1920s, the era in which this book is set. Women are struggling to find their place while still trained to please parents, authority figures, and for the most part, men in general.
If you have even a passing interest in classic literature you will appreciate this mystery.
The parallells shown, both in the literature being studied and in the lives of those involved, are masterfully presented. What happens on and between these pages and covers will take your breath away and make you think.
It deals with dark topics that are as timely today as they were in the 1920s, the era in which this book is set. Women are struggling to find their place while still trained to please parents, authority figures, and for the most part, men in general.
If you have even a passing interest in classic literature you will appreciate this mystery.
The parallells shown, both in the literature being studied and in the lives of those involved, are masterfully presented. What happens on and between these pages and covers will take your breath away and make you think.
February 27, 2018
This third Lady Evelyn book is probably my favorite of the series so far. Apart from the interesting (and relevant) mystery I have enjoyed the element of light heartedness in this book, the tongue in cheek moments, as well as her thoughts about life and the world in her time, often very relatable to our time and our questions as well.
For me, even though the story is really engaging, it is a character based book.
Evelyn and a number of other characters in the series feel very real, touchable, they draw me into their world and I would like to know them even better, just as I would like to know Charles Finch‘s character Lennox or Elly Griffiths‘ Ruth Galloway.
For me, even though the story is really engaging, it is a character based book.
Evelyn and a number of other characters in the series feel very real, touchable, they draw me into their world and I would like to know them even better, just as I would like to know Charles Finch‘s character Lennox or Elly Griffiths‘ Ruth Galloway.
March 21, 2018
Wonderful cozy mystery that takes you back in time... Which I am really starting to love these types of books! Event though this book is part of a series and as always I always recommend to read a series in order you can read this one as a stand a lone and be able to follow with no troubles.
June 9, 2018
This book was received from the publisher in return for an honest review
When I got the email asking if I’d like to take part in a weekend blog blitz for The Study of Silence I was intrigued, the plot sounded fascinating, and while I tend to stick to police procedurals by authors like Ian Rankin and Alex Gray, and more recently Carol Wyer and James Oswald I’ve read the odd book that falls into the cosy crime and mystery area of crime fiction and enjoyed them so I volunteered and I was certainly not disappointed!
Lady Evelyn Carlisle has returned to Oxford to complete her Classics degree at St. Hugh’s. Nearing the end of the Michaelmas term Evelyn and two of her housemates are invited to an end of term party at one of the tutor’s residences. Early the next morning Evelyn realises she has left her shawl behind at the Longfellow residence, deciding to retrieve it she drives across the city to discover her tutor’s door ajar and steps inside just as the maid discovers her master murdered in his study. Interviewed as a witness, Evelyn finds herself unable to keep away from the investigation, offering theories and discovering information from the officer in charge Inspector Stanton, she slowly becomes more involved to her detriment and the concern of Daniel and Briony.
The Study of Silence is actually the third book in the Lady Evelyn Carlisle Mysteries series, however I’ve not read either of the previous books and I don’t feel I’ve missed out at all – that’s not to say I won’t be going back to read the previous stories – just that The Study of Silence is perfectly enjoyable as a standalone novel and I didn’t feel I was missing out on vital information about the characters because I had not read the earlier works, although there were certainly hints about her time in Crete and France I would enjoy finding out more about.
There was a wonderful variety of characters within the novel.
Naturally the central character is Lady Evelyn herself, I was really drawn to her character, while her love of knowledge and wish for independence may not seem so unusual in the 21st century for the mid to late 1920’s this would mark her out as slightly unusual, not wanting to immediately settle down and take up her place as a wife and mother. I enjoyed Evelyn’s interactions with the other characters throughout the story, particularly her cousin and her family, Daniel and Inspector Stanton. Things may not always go exactly to plan for Evelyn as she finds herself in less the ideal situations, occasionally to the frustration of those around her, I feel she does everything she does from a genuine desire to help.
I also really enjoyed Inspector Stanton, we’re first introduced to him as Evelyn assists him and his son after they swerve off the road to avoid hitting an animal. I have to admit I loved the way he quickly became resigned to the fact Evelyn wanted to be involved with the case and shared information whilst trying to keep her safe as best he can. I also really enjoyed the little hints at his life, the introduction of his son Thom, small bits of information about his wife, and hints of some sort of disagreement with his scholar father. I would love to find out more about him in future stories.
I also liked Daniel, Evelyn’s partner, Briony, Evelyn’s cousin and her family, I get the impression that they feature more in the first two books, so I am keen to find out a little more about them!
And then we have Oxford! I feel like Oxford itself was a character within the novel, I do love things set in Oxford, with talk of its grand colleges and libraries, punting on the River Cherwell, the perfect setting for the story! While a couple of decades too early I could easily picture Endeavour Morse pulling up at the police station in a Jaguar, or popping out of one of the offices.
I felt the plot was well paced and full of hints and intrigue, the odd red herring but enough clues looking back to not feel cheated by the reveal.
Would I Recommend?
Yes, this is a wonderful read for anyone who loves a cosy crime mystery, or as a refreshing read between some darker crime fiction if that’s more your thing. I thoroughly enjoyed The Study of Silence and don’t feel I missed out from having not read the two earlier novels in the series. I’ll certainly be keeping my eyes out for any additional stories in this series and hoping this is not the last we’ve seen of Oxford and Inspector Stanton!
When I got the email asking if I’d like to take part in a weekend blog blitz for The Study of Silence I was intrigued, the plot sounded fascinating, and while I tend to stick to police procedurals by authors like Ian Rankin and Alex Gray, and more recently Carol Wyer and James Oswald I’ve read the odd book that falls into the cosy crime and mystery area of crime fiction and enjoyed them so I volunteered and I was certainly not disappointed!
Lady Evelyn Carlisle has returned to Oxford to complete her Classics degree at St. Hugh’s. Nearing the end of the Michaelmas term Evelyn and two of her housemates are invited to an end of term party at one of the tutor’s residences. Early the next morning Evelyn realises she has left her shawl behind at the Longfellow residence, deciding to retrieve it she drives across the city to discover her tutor’s door ajar and steps inside just as the maid discovers her master murdered in his study. Interviewed as a witness, Evelyn finds herself unable to keep away from the investigation, offering theories and discovering information from the officer in charge Inspector Stanton, she slowly becomes more involved to her detriment and the concern of Daniel and Briony.
The Study of Silence is actually the third book in the Lady Evelyn Carlisle Mysteries series, however I’ve not read either of the previous books and I don’t feel I’ve missed out at all – that’s not to say I won’t be going back to read the previous stories – just that The Study of Silence is perfectly enjoyable as a standalone novel and I didn’t feel I was missing out on vital information about the characters because I had not read the earlier works, although there were certainly hints about her time in Crete and France I would enjoy finding out more about.
There was a wonderful variety of characters within the novel.
Naturally the central character is Lady Evelyn herself, I was really drawn to her character, while her love of knowledge and wish for independence may not seem so unusual in the 21st century for the mid to late 1920’s this would mark her out as slightly unusual, not wanting to immediately settle down and take up her place as a wife and mother. I enjoyed Evelyn’s interactions with the other characters throughout the story, particularly her cousin and her family, Daniel and Inspector Stanton. Things may not always go exactly to plan for Evelyn as she finds herself in less the ideal situations, occasionally to the frustration of those around her, I feel she does everything she does from a genuine desire to help.
I also really enjoyed Inspector Stanton, we’re first introduced to him as Evelyn assists him and his son after they swerve off the road to avoid hitting an animal. I have to admit I loved the way he quickly became resigned to the fact Evelyn wanted to be involved with the case and shared information whilst trying to keep her safe as best he can. I also really enjoyed the little hints at his life, the introduction of his son Thom, small bits of information about his wife, and hints of some sort of disagreement with his scholar father. I would love to find out more about him in future stories.
I also liked Daniel, Evelyn’s partner, Briony, Evelyn’s cousin and her family, I get the impression that they feature more in the first two books, so I am keen to find out a little more about them!
And then we have Oxford! I feel like Oxford itself was a character within the novel, I do love things set in Oxford, with talk of its grand colleges and libraries, punting on the River Cherwell, the perfect setting for the story! While a couple of decades too early I could easily picture Endeavour Morse pulling up at the police station in a Jaguar, or popping out of one of the offices.
I felt the plot was well paced and full of hints and intrigue, the odd red herring but enough clues looking back to not feel cheated by the reveal.
Would I Recommend?
Yes, this is a wonderful read for anyone who loves a cosy crime mystery, or as a refreshing read between some darker crime fiction if that’s more your thing. I thoroughly enjoyed The Study of Silence and don’t feel I missed out from having not read the two earlier novels in the series. I’ll certainly be keeping my eyes out for any additional stories in this series and hoping this is not the last we’ve seen of Oxford and Inspector Stanton!
March 4, 2018
Despite being the third book in the Lady Evelyn series it didn’t matter that I hadn’t read the previous two; author Malia does a good job of introducing all of the new and existing characters.
Told from Evelyn, or Evie’s perspective I immediately was drawn to her as a character. Like any murder mystery “detective” Evie has a knack of being around when someone is killed. In this book she has returned from Greece and is studying Classics at Oxford. I loved the inclusion of Greek myth and history and how Evie makes the link between that and the case in question. I also really enjoyed the period it was set in (1926) and the exploration of Women’s Suffrage and the Impact of The Great War (World War 1). Through Evie the reader gets a nuanced observation of the times. I like how she is struggling with the concept of being a ‘modern woman’ whilst still being shackled by traditional expectations - especially that of the ‘ever-present-in-her- head’ Aunt Agnes. Evie’s own upbringing is very interesting and she is haunted by the death of her parents when she was young. I do wonder whether reading the earlier books in the series would have shed further light on that, or whether the series is even building up to exploring her history in more detail. Author Malia is already at work on the sixth Lady Evelyn mystery.
I found it intriguing how the red herrings started even before the murder, with me mis-guessing who the victim was going to be. And as ever suspicion on who the murderer is switches repeatedly.
I loved the link to the title and the concept of silence is really well explored in both subtle and more explicit ways.
If you are after a fast paced murder mystery with a swift denouement then this isn’t quite that read. But don’t let that put you off. Instead it is a clever exploration of love and the human condition in general with a well plotted murder mystery added. As with any good murder mystery series the story of the “detective” is also paramount and Lady Evelyn is a great character.
I will definitely be picking up the first two stories and continuing to read as each new book is released. Fans of the middle grade series Murder Most Unladylike by Robin Stevens or the young adult series Stalking Jack the Ripper by Kerri Maniscalco should enjoy this adult series too.
Thank you to Malia and Jenny of Neverland Blog Tours for the eARC of the book for the purpose of this honest review. This review also features on my blog.
Trigger Warning - Sexual Assault
Told from Evelyn, or Evie’s perspective I immediately was drawn to her as a character. Like any murder mystery “detective” Evie has a knack of being around when someone is killed. In this book she has returned from Greece and is studying Classics at Oxford. I loved the inclusion of Greek myth and history and how Evie makes the link between that and the case in question. I also really enjoyed the period it was set in (1926) and the exploration of Women’s Suffrage and the Impact of The Great War (World War 1). Through Evie the reader gets a nuanced observation of the times. I like how she is struggling with the concept of being a ‘modern woman’ whilst still being shackled by traditional expectations - especially that of the ‘ever-present-in-her- head’ Aunt Agnes. Evie’s own upbringing is very interesting and she is haunted by the death of her parents when she was young. I do wonder whether reading the earlier books in the series would have shed further light on that, or whether the series is even building up to exploring her history in more detail. Author Malia is already at work on the sixth Lady Evelyn mystery.
I found it intriguing how the red herrings started even before the murder, with me mis-guessing who the victim was going to be. And as ever suspicion on who the murderer is switches repeatedly.
I loved the link to the title and the concept of silence is really well explored in both subtle and more explicit ways.
If you are after a fast paced murder mystery with a swift denouement then this isn’t quite that read. But don’t let that put you off. Instead it is a clever exploration of love and the human condition in general with a well plotted murder mystery added. As with any good murder mystery series the story of the “detective” is also paramount and Lady Evelyn is a great character.
I will definitely be picking up the first two stories and continuing to read as each new book is released. Fans of the middle grade series Murder Most Unladylike by Robin Stevens or the young adult series Stalking Jack the Ripper by Kerri Maniscalco should enjoy this adult series too.
Thank you to Malia and Jenny of Neverland Blog Tours for the eARC of the book for the purpose of this honest review. This review also features on my blog.
Trigger Warning - Sexual Assault
November 16, 2018
Lady Evelyn is back in England. Both she and Daniel have returned to England after a long vacation and much excitement. She’s in Oxford and he is in London. They see each other on sporadic weekends. He returned for his family business and she to attend a women’s college in Oxford. All is copacetic until a murder takes place involving a professor and Evie can’t help but look for and track down clues. It is in this quest where the story tension and conflict arises and the author involves the reader in all the antics we, the fans, have grown to love about Lady Evelyn’s way of tackling life. And murder. The levity enters with the way in which she interjects herself into “her” investigation and I laughed out loud as a giant rat ran across her foot as she’s practicing being very stealth. The writing is rich in historical reference and held me wanting to know how the mystery would be solved. And even when it’s solved another mystery and revelation occurs to add an icing to the luscious storytelling. This is a timely novel in that it tackles women’s issues: in the twenties women were in the minority in colleges international, the challenges post-graduation, and the struggles of the working class woman. These themes run deep and resonate contemporary which adds to the depth of the read. Evie struggles with her own issues, namely that of her deceased parents, taking during a fire, what does she do with the family estate that is too painful for her to return to and her other family members feel the same forcing her to confront letting go, and then there are issues with committing to Daniel. The writing is tight and intriguing with the big picture mystery: the murder; and the smaller mysteries: how will Evie sort out her own issues. The scenery and dialogue flow like honey from chapter to chapter. The characters are authentic, none perfect or without the human struggle we all can relate to. A delightful, enjoyable read right down to the surprising ending.
April 19, 2018
This book is the 3rd in a series but can be read as a stand-alone. However, I think I would have preferred to have read the other 2 in the series as this book references back a lot. Almost everything from the other 2 books are explained without any major spoilers, which I was glad of.
I enjoyed the main character, Lady Evelyn, and seeing her develop as the story unfolded. I also really enjoyed how progressive the female characters were in this book. They were not afraid to push boundaries and be heard in a time in which women were still seen to be inferior.
The mystery in this book is also very enjoyable. If you’re looking for a slow burn of a mystery with lots of twists and turns then this is the story for you. I love a good murder mystery and really enjoyed how this story unfolded and turned out.
The book is set in Oxford which is a thing that I loved as I visit Oxford often. It was lovely being able to picture Evie in all the situations in all the places I have come to know so well.
I would say that it takes a little time to get into the story,. However, once it does get into all the mystery it really gets into it.
I enjoyed the main character, Lady Evelyn, and seeing her develop as the story unfolded. I also really enjoyed how progressive the female characters were in this book. They were not afraid to push boundaries and be heard in a time in which women were still seen to be inferior.
The mystery in this book is also very enjoyable. If you’re looking for a slow burn of a mystery with lots of twists and turns then this is the story for you. I love a good murder mystery and really enjoyed how this story unfolded and turned out.
The book is set in Oxford which is a thing that I loved as I visit Oxford often. It was lovely being able to picture Evie in all the situations in all the places I have come to know so well.
I would say that it takes a little time to get into the story,. However, once it does get into all the mystery it really gets into it.
March 11, 2018
*This ARC was received in exchange for an honest review*
Set in the 1920’s this is the story of Lady Evelyn Carlisle who has returned to Oxford to finish her degree at St Hugh’s Women’s College.
It seems that trouble finds Evie again where she comes across a murder, but that doesn’t stop her trying to investigate this murder herself by tracking down the clues and putting herself in danger much to the chagrin of the new Police Detective Lucas Stanton and her family.
Reading this is so reminded me of the Miss Fisher’s murder Mysteries and like Phryne Fisher, Evie is an independent woman and her study’s focus on womens issues in a time when it was a mans world.
Although this can be read as a standalone, I would recommend reading the first two books in the series to get an idea on the characters, especially Evie.
Look forward to the next instalment in the Lady Evelyn Mystery Series by Malia Zaidi.
Set in the 1920’s this is the story of Lady Evelyn Carlisle who has returned to Oxford to finish her degree at St Hugh’s Women’s College.
It seems that trouble finds Evie again where she comes across a murder, but that doesn’t stop her trying to investigate this murder herself by tracking down the clues and putting herself in danger much to the chagrin of the new Police Detective Lucas Stanton and her family.
Reading this is so reminded me of the Miss Fisher’s murder Mysteries and like Phryne Fisher, Evie is an independent woman and her study’s focus on womens issues in a time when it was a mans world.
Although this can be read as a standalone, I would recommend reading the first two books in the series to get an idea on the characters, especially Evie.
Look forward to the next instalment in the Lady Evelyn Mystery Series by Malia Zaidi.
August 14, 2018
Another great edition. When is the next coming out?
I enjoy these books even more than other historical fiction mysteries because they are so embedded in real places I can google earth to my heart’s content. I have been physically to Oxford, but now the narration has taken me down the streets, and into buildings. Thanks!
I enjoy these books even more than other historical fiction mysteries because they are so embedded in real places I can google earth to my heart’s content. I have been physically to Oxford, but now the narration has taken me down the streets, and into buildings. Thanks!
October 1, 2020
The tone of this story was a bit different than the first book in the series (I have not read the second one). Evelyn is much more introspective: contemplating man's nature, good and evil, what she should do with her life after graduation, the meaning of life. This maybe because she is older and has had more experience and/or because she is in a place where such contemplations are expected, Oxford. It is interesting to see Evelyn's growth but they go on for a bit too long in places.
Overall, a good story and a solid mystery. I didn't guess the murderer until the end.
Overall, a good story and a solid mystery. I didn't guess the murderer until the end.
April 14, 2019
3.5 stars
This third entry in the Lady Evelyn series was a bit unsatisfying. After the brilliant second book, this one seemed to spend a little too much time in philosophizing. And what has seemed to be admirable independence in the main character is beginning to feel like persistent foolhardiness.
Lady Evelyn, after tragically losing her parents at a very young age and being raised by a stern aunt, seems to finally be coming to terms with her life situation. The series began when she bravely escaped from society's confines by joining a cousin's family in Crete.
By this time, she has returned to England and is living in Oxford finishing her university studies. We admire her strength and self-reliance and she revels in her courses in the Classics. She is an unusual woman for her era, the 1920's. She appreciates her independent living situation and is not in a hurry to marry her beau, Daniel, in spite of her love for him.
But her scholastic interlude is besmirched when she stumbled upon a murder while attending a dinner at her tutor's house. A whole host of secrets begin to spin out as the investigation digs deeper.
The mystery is a little on the unbelievable side, and we can't quite figure out why Lady Evelyn is so obsessed with inserting herself into the middle of the case. But I do like this main character, the era and setting, and the writing style.
Thanks to Net Galley for providing me with an ARC in exchange for my honest review.
This third entry in the Lady Evelyn series was a bit unsatisfying. After the brilliant second book, this one seemed to spend a little too much time in philosophizing. And what has seemed to be admirable independence in the main character is beginning to feel like persistent foolhardiness.
Lady Evelyn, after tragically losing her parents at a very young age and being raised by a stern aunt, seems to finally be coming to terms with her life situation. The series began when she bravely escaped from society's confines by joining a cousin's family in Crete.
By this time, she has returned to England and is living in Oxford finishing her university studies. We admire her strength and self-reliance and she revels in her courses in the Classics. She is an unusual woman for her era, the 1920's. She appreciates her independent living situation and is not in a hurry to marry her beau, Daniel, in spite of her love for him.
But her scholastic interlude is besmirched when she stumbled upon a murder while attending a dinner at her tutor's house. A whole host of secrets begin to spin out as the investigation digs deeper.
The mystery is a little on the unbelievable side, and we can't quite figure out why Lady Evelyn is so obsessed with inserting herself into the middle of the case. But I do like this main character, the era and setting, and the writing style.
Thanks to Net Galley for providing me with an ARC in exchange for my honest review.
May 16, 2019
Great story
Looking forward to the next book. This female protagonist is a winner. I do wish she would make up her mind about Daniel though. 😀
Looking forward to the next book. This female protagonist is a winner. I do wish she would make up her mind about Daniel though. 😀
March 12, 2018
An entertaining historical cozy mystery. Even if it isn't the first instalment in the series I had no problems in understanding the characters and their relationship.
Well written and well developed, it was a nice and entertaining reading.
Many thanks to Netgalley and Bookbaby
Well written and well developed, it was a nice and entertaining reading.
Many thanks to Netgalley and Bookbaby
May 7, 2018
The Lady Evelyn mysteries will appeal to fans of cozies set in the 1920s. The Study of Silence in the third Lady Evelyn novel, but it is not necessary to read the novels in order.
In The Study of Silence, Lady Evelyn Carlisle is back at Oxford working on finishing her degree. Trouble, however is near at hand, and soon one of St Hugh’s respected tutors is found dead, murdered. Suspicion falls on his wife, but Lady Evelyn is certain she is innocent. The more she investigates, the more certain she becomes that the crime is linked to the victim’s abuse of women. Although this is a historical mystery, it brings up many current issues regarding the treatment of women, physical and sexual abuse, and the tendency to blame the victim.
The Study of Silence is an excellent cozy, well researched, with characters that can be understood and empathized with. If all of Malia Zaidi’s novels are this good, then her series is definite to be a success.
5 / 5
I received a copy of The Study of Silence from the publisher and Netgalley.com in exchange for an honest review.
-- Crittermom
In The Study of Silence, Lady Evelyn Carlisle is back at Oxford working on finishing her degree. Trouble, however is near at hand, and soon one of St Hugh’s respected tutors is found dead, murdered. Suspicion falls on his wife, but Lady Evelyn is certain she is innocent. The more she investigates, the more certain she becomes that the crime is linked to the victim’s abuse of women. Although this is a historical mystery, it brings up many current issues regarding the treatment of women, physical and sexual abuse, and the tendency to blame the victim.
The Study of Silence is an excellent cozy, well researched, with characters that can be understood and empathized with. If all of Malia Zaidi’s novels are this good, then her series is definite to be a success.
5 / 5
I received a copy of The Study of Silence from the publisher and Netgalley.com in exchange for an honest review.
-- Crittermom
Displaying 1 - 25 of 25 reviews